Maya Hughes' The Third Best Thing is a delightful addition to the contemporary romance genre, weaving a tale of love, secrets, and the complexities of human connection. Set against the backdrop of college life at Fulton University, the story revolves around two main characters: Berk, a charming and somewhat impulsive young man, and Jules, the sweet and endearing girl next door. Their journey is not just about finding a mysterious pen pal but also about discovering themselves and each other in the process.

The premise of the novel is intriguing from the outset. Berk, who has been exchanging flirty letters with a woman he knows only as "The Letter Girl," finds himself in a predicament when she suddenly stops responding. In a twist of fate, he enlists the help of Jules, his neighbor, who unbeknownst to him, is actually the very person he is searching for. This setup creates a delicious tension that drives the narrative forward, as readers are left wondering how long Jules can keep her secret and what will happen when the truth is finally revealed.

One of the standout themes in The Third Best Thing is the exploration of identity and self-discovery. Both Berk and Jules are at pivotal points in their lives, navigating the uncertainties of young adulthood. Berk's character is particularly well-developed; he is portrayed as a man who is both confident and vulnerable, grappling with his feelings for Jules while still holding onto the fantasy of his pen pal. This duality makes him relatable and endearing, as readers can empathize with his struggles between reality and fantasy.

Jules, on the other hand, embodies the theme of fear of rejection. Her reluctance to reveal her identity to Berk stems from a deep-seated insecurity that many readers will find familiar. Hughes captures the essence of this fear beautifully, illustrating how it can hinder personal connections and prevent individuals from pursuing what they truly want. Jules' character arc is compelling; as she learns to embrace her true self and confront her fears, readers are treated to a satisfying transformation that is both realistic and inspiring.

The chemistry between Berk and Jules is palpable and expertly crafted. Hughes employs witty banter and tender moments to build their relationship, making it easy for readers to root for them. The author’s ability to create tension through their interactions is commendable; every stolen glance and shared laugh adds layers to their connection, making the eventual revelation of Jules' identity all the more impactful. The emotional stakes are high, and Hughes does not shy away from exploring the potential fallout of their secretive dynamic.

Another notable aspect of the novel is its exploration of friendship and support systems. Berk and Jules are surrounded by a cast of secondary characters who enrich the narrative. Their friends provide comic relief and wisdom, grounding the story in a sense of community that is often found in college settings. This element adds depth to the plot, as it highlights the importance of having a support system during times of uncertainty and change.

Hughes' writing style is engaging and accessible, making the book a page-turner. Her use of humor and relatable dialogue keeps the tone light, even when delving into deeper emotional themes. The pacing is well-balanced, allowing for moments of tension and introspection without dragging the story down. Readers will find themselves invested in the characters' journeys, eagerly flipping pages to see how their stories unfold.

In comparison to other contemporary romances, The Third Best Thing stands out for its unique premise and character-driven narrative. While many romance novels focus solely on the romantic relationship, Hughes skillfully intertwines themes of self-discovery and personal growth, making it a more enriching read. Fans of authors like Christina Lauren and Tessa Bailey will likely appreciate Hughes' ability to blend humor with heartfelt moments, creating a story that resonates on multiple levels.

Ultimately, The Third Best Thing is a celebration of love in its many forms—romantic, platonic, and self-love. It reminds readers that the journey to finding oneself is often fraught with challenges, but it is also filled with moments of joy and connection. Hughes has crafted a story that is not only entertaining but also thought-provoking, encouraging readers to reflect on their own relationships and the importance of being true to oneself.

In conclusion, Maya Hughes has delivered a charming and engaging romance that will leave readers with a smile. With its relatable characters, witty dialogue, and heartfelt themes, The Third Best Thing is a must-read for anyone who enjoys a good love story with depth. Whether you're a fan of contemporary romance or simply looking for a delightful escape, this book is sure to captivate your heart.