Maya Hughes’ The Fourth Time Charm is a captivating addition to the Fulton U series, weaving a tale of friendship, desire, and the complexities of young love against the backdrop of college sports. The story centers around two main characters, the charming and ambitious athlete, and his lifelong best friend, Marisa, who finds herself in a precarious situation as their relationship evolves. Hughes skillfully navigates the themes of loyalty, ambition, and the struggle between personal desires and professional responsibilities, making this novel a compelling read for fans of contemporary romance.

From the outset, the tension is palpable. The opening line, “Are you sleeping with my daughter?” sets the stage for a story filled with forbidden romance and the weight of expectations. The protagonist, whose future hinges on his performance in sports, finds himself torn between his burgeoning feelings for Marisa and the potential repercussions of pursuing a relationship with her. This conflict is not only relatable but also adds a layer of depth to the narrative, as it explores the sacrifices one must make in the pursuit of dreams.

Hughes excels in character development, particularly in how she portrays the evolution of the relationship between the two leads. The protagonist’s internal struggle is vividly depicted; he grapples with his feelings for Marisa while trying to maintain a façade of professionalism. The author does an excellent job of illustrating the nuances of their friendship—how years of shared experiences and deep emotional connections can blur the lines between platonic and romantic love. As they navigate their senior year, the reader witnesses the transformation of their bond, which is both heartwarming and fraught with tension.

Marisa is a well-rounded character, portrayed as strong and independent yet vulnerable in her feelings for her best friend. Her need for support during a challenging time in her life adds layers to her character, making her relatable and endearing. The dynamic between her and the protagonist is rich with chemistry, and Hughes captures the essence of their connection through intimate moments that feel genuine and heartfelt. The “movie Thursdays under the blankets” and “study sessions on my bed” are not just plot devices; they symbolize the comfort and safety of their friendship, which becomes increasingly complicated as their feelings deepen.

One of the standout themes in The Fourth Time Charm is the idea of risk—both in love and in life. The protagonist’s fear of jeopardizing his future is a central conflict that resonates with anyone who has ever faced a difficult choice. Hughes effectively portrays the tension between ambition and personal happiness, prompting readers to reflect on what they are willing to sacrifice for love. This theme is further emphasized by the looming presence of the coach, who embodies the authority and pressure that often accompany the pursuit of athletic excellence. The stakes are high, and Hughes keeps readers on the edge of their seats as the characters navigate their feelings while trying to keep their relationship a secret.

The pacing of the novel is well-executed, with a balance of light-hearted moments and intense emotional scenes. Hughes knows when to inject humor into the narrative, providing relief from the tension and allowing readers to connect with the characters on a more personal level. The dialogue is sharp and witty, capturing the essence of college life and the playful banter that often characterizes young relationships. This balance of humor and seriousness is reminiscent of works by authors like Elle Kennedy and Sarina Bowen, who also explore the complexities of college romance with a similar blend of levity and depth.

As the story progresses, the stakes become even higher, leading to a climax that is both satisfying and thought-provoking. Hughes does not shy away from addressing the consequences of the characters’ choices, forcing them to confront the reality of their situation. This moment of reckoning is pivotal, as it challenges both characters to evaluate their priorities and the true nature of their feelings for one another. The resolution is both realistic and hopeful, leaving readers with a sense of closure while also hinting at the possibilities that lie ahead.

In conclusion, The Fourth Time Charm is a beautifully crafted romance that explores the intricacies of friendship and love in the face of ambition and societal expectations. Maya Hughes has created a world that feels authentic and relatable, drawing readers into the lives of her characters with ease. The themes of risk, loyalty, and the pursuit of happiness resonate throughout the narrative, making it a thought-provoking read that lingers long after the last page is turned. For fans of contemporary romance, this book is a must-read, offering a delightful blend of tension, humor, and heartfelt moments that will leave you rooting for the characters until the very end.