Monica Murphy's You Were Never Not Mine is a compelling exploration of the complexities of young love, power dynamics, and the journey of self-discovery. Set against the backdrop of Lancaster Prep and later a university setting, the novel delves into the tumultuous relationship between August Lancaster and Sinclair, two characters whose paths are intertwined by fate and circumstance.

The story begins with Sinclair's introduction to the intimidating world of Lancaster Prep, where August Lancaster reigns supreme. August's influence is palpable, and his presence is both alluring and terrifying. Murphy crafts August as a character who embodies the archetype of the untouchable high school king, yet she skillfully layers his persona with depth and vulnerability. This duality is what makes August a fascinating character to follow. His initial interactions with Sinclair are marked by a blend of cruelty and fascination, setting the stage for a complex relationship that evolves throughout the novel.

Sinclair, on the other hand, is portrayed as a resilient and determined young woman. Her journey from a freshman overwhelmed by August's attention to a college student ready to confront her past is both relatable and inspiring. Murphy does an excellent job of capturing Sinclair's internal struggles, her desire to assert her identity, and her conflicting emotions towards August. The transformation of Sinclair's character is one of the novel's highlights, as she navigates the fine line between hatred and attraction, ultimately discovering her own strength and agency.

The theme of power dynamics is central to the narrative. August's initial treatment of Sinclair is a reflection of the unchecked power he wields at Lancaster Prep. However, as the story progresses, Murphy challenges this dynamic by placing Sinclair in situations where she can reclaim her power. The shift in their relationship is gradual and believable, allowing readers to witness the growth of both characters. This exploration of power and its impact on relationships is a thought-provoking aspect of the novel, prompting readers to consider the ways in which power can be both destructive and transformative.

Murphy's writing style is engaging and evocative, capturing the intensity of Sinclair and August's emotions with precision. The dialogue is sharp and realistic, adding depth to the characters and their interactions. The pacing of the novel is well-balanced, with moments of tension and introspection interspersed with lighter, more humorous scenes. This balance keeps the reader invested in the story, eager to see how Sinclair and August's relationship will unfold.

One of the most compelling aspects of You Were Never Not Mine is its exploration of the theme of change and redemption. August's journey from a seemingly irredeemable antagonist to a character capable of growth and change is handled with nuance. Murphy avoids the trap of a simplistic redemption arc, instead presenting a realistic portrayal of a young man grappling with his past actions and striving to become a better person. This theme resonates with readers, offering a message of hope and the possibility of change, even for those who seem beyond redemption.

In comparison to similar stories in the genre, such as Elle Kennedy's The Deal or Penelope Douglas's Bully, Murphy's novel stands out for its focus on character development and emotional depth. While both Kennedy and Douglas explore themes of power and attraction, Murphy's emphasis on the internal struggles of her characters and their journey towards self-discovery adds a layer of complexity that sets her work apart. The novel's exploration of the blurred lines between love and hate, attraction and repulsion, is reminiscent of Douglas's work, yet Murphy's unique voice and perspective make You Were Never Not Mine a standout in its own right.

Overall, You Were Never Not Mine is a captivating and emotionally resonant novel that will appeal to fans of contemporary romance and coming-of-age stories. Monica Murphy has crafted a tale that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, offering readers a glimpse into the complexities of young love and the power of personal growth. The novel's themes of power, change, and redemption are skillfully woven into a narrative that is as engaging as it is insightful. For those looking for a story that challenges the conventions of the genre while delivering a satisfying and heartfelt romance, You Were Never Not Mine is a must-read.