Roxanne Tully's Wrong Twin is a captivating exploration of mistaken identities, unrequited love, and the complexities of sibling rivalry, set against the backdrop of professional sports and high-stakes finance. The novel deftly weaves a tale that is as much about personal growth and self-discovery as it is about romance and deception.

The story kicks off with a compelling premise: Harper Maxwell, a woman who has long harbored feelings for Troy Hartman, finds herself entangled in a case of mistaken identity when she kisses his twin brother, August. This initial setup is not only intriguing but also sets the stage for a series of events that challenge the characters' perceptions of themselves and each other.

**August Hartman** emerges as a complex and relatable protagonist. Unlike his brother Troy, who is deeply entrenched in the world of professional hockey, August is more at home in the world of finance. His character is meticulously crafted, with Tully providing a nuanced portrayal of a man who has always lived in the shadow of his more flamboyant twin. August's internal struggle between loyalty to his brother and his own desires forms the crux of his character arc. His journey from being a passive observer of his own life to taking charge of his destiny is both compelling and inspiring.

**Harper Maxwell** is equally well-developed. Her initial infatuation with Troy is portrayed with authenticity, capturing the essence of youthful crushes and the idealization that often accompanies them. However, as the story progresses, Harper's character undergoes significant growth. She evolves from a woman who is defined by her feelings for Troy to someone who recognizes her own worth and desires. Her interactions with August are particularly noteworthy, as they reveal layers of her personality that were previously unexplored.

The theme of mistaken identity is handled with finesse. Tully uses this trope not just as a plot device, but as a means to delve deeper into the characters' psyches. The confusion between the twins serves as a metaphor for the characters' own internal conflicts and the masks they wear in their daily lives. This theme is further enriched by the backdrop of professional sports, where identity and public perception play crucial roles.

Another significant theme in Wrong Twin is the idea of **regret and redemption**. Both August and Harper grapple with past decisions and missed opportunities. August's regret over not pursuing Harper earlier and Harper's realization that her feelings for Troy were misplaced add depth to their relationship. Tully skillfully portrays how these regrets can either hold individuals back or propel them towards growth and change.

The novel also touches upon the dynamics of sibling rivalry. The contrast between August and Troy is stark, yet believable. Tully avoids caricaturing Troy as merely the 'bad' twin; instead, she presents him as a flawed but ultimately human character. This nuanced portrayal adds layers to the story, making the reader empathize with both brothers despite their differences.

In terms of writing style, Tully's prose is engaging and accessible. She has a knack for crafting dialogue that feels authentic and natural, which enhances the chemistry between the characters. The pacing of the novel is well-balanced, with moments of tension and introspection interspersed with lighter, more humorous scenes. This balance ensures that the reader remains invested in the story from start to finish.

Comparatively, Wrong Twin shares thematic similarities with other romance novels that explore mistaken identities and sibling dynamics, such as Christina Lauren's Josh and Hazel's Guide to Not Dating and Sally Thorne's The Hating Game. However, Tully's novel stands out due to its unique setting and the depth of its character development. While the mistaken identity trope is a common one, Tully's execution is fresh and engaging, making it a standout in the genre.

Overall, Roxanne Tully's Wrong Twin is a delightful read that offers more than just a simple romance. It is a story about finding one's true self amidst the chaos of life and love. With its well-drawn characters, engaging plot, and thoughtful exploration of themes, the novel is sure to resonate with readers who appreciate romance with depth and substance. Whether you're a fan of sports romances or stories about personal growth, Wrong Twin is a book that promises to leave a lasting impression.