With Wine Comes War by J.E. Johnson is a compelling narrative that intertwines the rich, heady essence of wine with the stark, often harsh realities of war, presenting readers with a unique perspective on human resilience, passion, and the complexities of moral choices amidst turmoil. This novel, set against the lush vineyards of France during World War II, provides not only a profound exploration of history but also a deep dive into the human spirit.

The story follows protagonist Marcel Dupont, a seasoned viticulturist, whose tranquil life tending to his family’s century-old vineyard is abruptly shattered by the onset of war. The author, J.E. Johnson, masterfully captures the initial tranquility of the vineyard, making the impending chaos all the more jarring. As German forces invade and occupy France, Marcel is faced with choices that entangle his love for his family, his dedication to his craft, and his loyalty to his country.

Johnson's exploration of Marcel’s character is nuanced and thorough. Marcel is portrayed not just as a winemaker, but as a multifaceted individual battling internal and external conflicts. He grapples with collaboration to save his vineyard and protect his family, or resistance to preserve his integrity and support his country. This moral dilemma is a recurring theme and is handled with grace and depth by Johnson, providing a thoughtful insight into the often grey areas of wartime ethics.

The narrative is rich with descriptions of winemaking processes, from the picking of grapes to the delicate fermentation stages, which Johnson describes with meticulous care, showing a respect for the craft that mirrors Marcel’s own reverence. This detailed portrayal serves as a poignant metaphor for control and the lack thereof, paralleling the unpredictability of war with the finesse of winemaking, where both demand patience, resilience, and a tolerance for uncertainty.

Supporting characters in the novel add layers of complexity and humanity to the story. We meet figures such as Annette, Marcel’s stoic wife, whose unwavering support and incisive wisdom are his anchors, and Pierre, the youthful resistance fighter whose idealism and bravery ignite crucial action in the plot. Each character is well-developed, with backstories that add emotional depth and motivations that are relatable and real. The antagonist, a high-ranking German officer with a penchant for fine wine, is equally well crafted, providing a foil to Marcel and bringing a nuanced perspective to the enemy, complicating Marcel’s and the reader’s feelings towards him.

Thematically, With Wine Comes War delves deeply into the struggles of preserving one's cultural and personal identities against the backdrop of conflict and loss. Wine, as Johnson illustrates, is much more than a beverage; it’s a symbol of tradition, of years of labor and love, and ultimately, of the culture that the war threatens to destroy. This symbolic resonance is one of the book's greatest strengths, offering readers not only a tale of war but a commentary on what it means to fight for one’s heritage.

Johnson's writing style is eloquent and evocative, adept at pulling the reader into the era with historical accuracies and vivid imagery that paints a realistic portrait of 1940s France. The pacing of the novel is generally well-handled, though some sections dealing with the intricacies of vineyard management may seem slow to readers less fascinated with viniculture. However, these moments are integral to understanding the protagonist's world and his connection to the land.

The resolution of the novel is satisfying yet heart-wrenching, staying true to the historical context while providing a personal closure for Marcel’s journey. This end, without giving away any spoilers, speaks volumes about the enduring human spirit and the sacrifices made in the name of love and duty. It’s a poignant conclusion that resonates well after turning the last page.

In conclusion, With Wine Comes War by J.E. Johnson is a profound and beautifully written novel that offers more than just a historical narrative. It is a thoughtful exploration of the human condition under duress, a celebration of an artisan's love for his craft, and a poignant reminder of the enduring spirit of a community facing the ravages of war. Readers interested in WWII history, those fascinated by the art of winemaking, or anyone looking for a deeply human story will find much to admire and ponder in this exceptional book.