Lia Amador's Witch You Would is a delightful foray into a world where magic and reality television collide, offering readers a whimsical yet heartfelt narrative that explores themes of identity, ambition, and romance. Set against the vibrant backdrop of Miami, where enchantment is as commonplace as a college major, Amador crafts a story that is both enchanting and relatable.

The novel introduces us to Penelope Delmar, a young witch struggling to make ends meet as a salesgirl. Her life takes an unexpected turn when she is selected to compete on Cast Judgment, a spellcasting reality show that promises a substantial cash prize. The twist? This season is the Spellebrity Edition, meaning each contestant is paired with a celebrity teammate. Enter Leandro Presto, or rather, Gil Contreras, a man hiding behind a persona known for his comedic viral spell videos rather than his magical prowess.

Amador deftly uses the reality show setting to explore the pressures and absurdities of fame and public perception. The concept of a magical reality show is both innovative and entertaining, providing a fresh take on the familiar trope of competition-based narratives. The stakes are high, not just for the prize money but also for the personal growth and relationships that develop throughout the competition.

The character development in Witch You Would is particularly noteworthy. Penelope is a well-rounded protagonist whose journey is both compelling and relatable. Her initial disdain for Leandro Presto is rooted in her perception of him as a frivolous entertainer, yet as the story unfolds, she discovers the depth and sincerity of Gil Contreras. This evolution is mirrored in Gil's character, who must navigate the complexities of maintaining his persona while yearning to reveal his true self to Penelope.

The chemistry between Penelope and Gil is palpable, and Amador skillfully builds their relationship with a mix of humor, tension, and genuine emotion. Their dynamic is reminiscent of classic romantic comedies, where initial misunderstandings and prejudices give way to mutual respect and affection. The added layer of magical mishaps and sabotage attempts injects a sense of urgency and excitement, keeping readers engaged and invested in their journey.

One of the novel's strengths lies in its exploration of identity and authenticity. Gil's struggle to reconcile his public persona with his true self is a poignant commentary on the pressures of maintaining a facade in the age of social media and celebrity culture. Similarly, Penelope's journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns to embrace her talents and assert her worth in a world that often underestimates her.

Amador's writing is both witty and evocative, capturing the vibrant energy of Miami and the enchanting allure of magic. Her attention to detail brings the world of Witch You Would to life, from the intricacies of spellcasting to the glitzy spectacle of the reality show. The pacing is well-balanced, with moments of introspection interspersed with action-packed sequences that keep the narrative moving forward.

In comparison to other works in the genre, Witch You Would stands out for its unique blend of magic and reality television. Fans of Sarah J. Maas's A Court of Thorns and Roses series or Stephanie Garber's Caraval will appreciate Amador's ability to weave fantasy elements into a contemporary setting. However, where Amador truly shines is in her ability to infuse humor and heart into her storytelling, making Witch You Would a refreshing and enjoyable read.

Overall, Witch You Would is a charming and engaging novel that offers a perfect blend of magic, romance, and adventure. Lia Amador has crafted a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of identity, ambition, and love. Whether you're a fan of fantasy, romance, or reality TV, this book is sure to cast a spell on you.