Melissa Wiesner's Wish I Were Here is a delightful exploration of identity, self-discovery, and the unexpected turns life can take. This novel, with its engaging premise and charming characters, offers a refreshing take on the romantic comedy genre, making it a must-read for fans of Sophie Cousens, Ashley Poston, and Josie Silver.

The story centers around Catherine Lipton, a math professor whose life is as meticulously organized as a well-balanced equation. Her penchant for order is not just a professional trait but a personal necessity, stemming from a childhood marked by unpredictability under the care of her free-spirited single father. Catherine's life is a testament to the power of routine and planning, but beneath her structured exterior lies a yearning for something more—a desire to break free from the confines of her own making.

Wiesner cleverly sets the stage for Catherine's transformation by introducing a crisis that shatters her carefully constructed world: the mysterious disappearance of her identity. This intriguing plot device serves as both a literal and metaphorical catalyst for change. As Catherine grapples with the loss of her social security number, driver's license, and academic records, she is forced to confront the more profound question of who she truly is beyond these identifiers.

Enter Luca Morelli, Catherine's doorman, whose laid-back demeanor and devil-may-care attitude stand in stark contrast to her own. Luca is the embodiment of spontaneity and charm, qualities that both infuriate and intrigue Catherine. Their dynamic is a classic case of opposites attracting, and Wiesner skillfully navigates their evolving relationship with humor and heart. Luca's role in Catherine's journey is pivotal; he not only aids her in the practical aspects of reclaiming her identity but also challenges her to embrace the unpredictability of life.

The chemistry between Catherine and Luca is palpable, and their interactions are laced with witty banter that keeps the narrative lively. As they embark on a series of adventures—from clandestine meetings in smoky bars to daring escapades in hospital record rooms—Catherine begins to shed her rigid exterior and discovers a newfound sense of freedom. Wiesner's portrayal of their relationship is both endearing and realistic, capturing the complexities of two individuals learning to navigate their differences while finding common ground.

One of the novel's standout themes is the exploration of identity and the notion that it is not solely defined by external markers. Catherine's journey is a poignant reminder that true identity is an amalgamation of experiences, choices, and personal growth. As she delves deeper into the mystery of her vanished identity, Catherine uncovers layers of herself that have long been buried beneath her need for control. This theme resonates with readers who may find themselves questioning their own identities in a world that often prioritizes labels and achievements.

Wiesner's writing is both engaging and insightful, with a keen eye for detail that brings the story to life. Her ability to balance humor with introspection is commendable, allowing readers to connect with Catherine's struggles while enjoying the lighter moments of the narrative. The pacing of the novel is well-executed, with each chapter revealing new facets of the characters and advancing the plot in a way that keeps readers invested.

In comparison to other works in the genre, Wish I Were Here stands out for its unique premise and the depth of its character development. While it shares the romantic charm of Sophie Cousens' This Time Next Year and the whimsical elements of Ashley Poston's The Dead Romantics, Wiesner's novel delves deeper into the theme of self-discovery. The mystery surrounding Catherine's identity adds an element of intrigue that sets it apart from more conventional romantic comedies.

Overall, Wish I Were Here is a captivating read that offers both entertainment and introspection. Melissa Wiesner has crafted a story that is as heartwarming as it is thought-provoking, inviting readers to reflect on their own identities and the paths they choose to follow. With its engaging characters, witty dialogue, and compelling themes, this novel is sure to resonate with anyone who has ever wished for a different life or questioned their place in the world.

In conclusion, Wiesner's novel is a testament to the power of storytelling to illuminate the complexities of human experience. Wish I Were Here is not just a love story; it is a celebration of the journey to self-discovery and the unexpected joys that come with embracing the unknown. For readers seeking a book that combines romance, humor, and a touch of mystery, this novel is a perfect choice.