Jeannette Winters' When We Were Eighteen is a compelling narrative that delves into the intricate web of family secrets, personal missions, and unexpected love. The book introduces us to Damien Blaze, a character whose life mission is to reunite families, a task he approaches with unwavering dedication and a unique set of skills. However, his latest case challenges his usual modus operandi, pushing him into uncharted emotional territory.

The premise of the novel is intriguing from the outset. Damien is not dealing with a typical missing person case; instead, he is tasked with uncovering the whereabouts of MaKayla, a woman hidden from her family for over two decades. This setup immediately sets the stage for a narrative rich in mystery and emotional complexity. Winters skillfully crafts a story that is not just about finding a missing person but about uncovering the layers of secrecy and protection that have kept MaKayla away from her family.

One of the standout elements of When We Were Eighteen is its exploration of the theme of protection versus freedom. Damien's protective instincts are central to his character, and as he becomes more involved in MaKayla's life, these instincts are both his strength and his vulnerability. Winters does an excellent job of portraying Damien's internal struggle as he balances his professional duty with his growing personal feelings for MaKayla. This conflict adds depth to his character and keeps the reader engaged as they navigate the complexities of his emotions.

MaKayla, on the other hand, is a character shrouded in mystery. Her past and the reasons for her hidden existence are gradually revealed, keeping the reader hooked. Winters' portrayal of MaKayla is nuanced; she is not just a damsel in distress but a woman with her own strengths and fears. The dynamic between Damien and MaKayla is central to the narrative, and their evolving relationship is handled with sensitivity and realism. As they grow closer, the tension between their personal desires and the looming threat of MaKayla's past creates a compelling emotional arc.

The novel also delves into the broader theme of family and the lengths to which people will go to protect their loved ones. Winters explores the idea that family is not just about blood relations but about the connections we choose to nurture. This theme resonates throughout the book, adding layers to the characters' motivations and actions. The author’s ability to weave this theme into the narrative without it feeling forced is commendable, making the story both relatable and thought-provoking.

In terms of pacing, When We Were Eighteen strikes a balance between suspense and character development. Winters ensures that the plot moves forward at a steady pace, with enough twists and turns to keep the reader engaged. The suspense is not just about the mystery of MaKayla's past but also about the emotional stakes for the characters involved. This dual-layered suspense is a testament to Winters' skill as a storyteller, as she keeps the reader invested in both the plot and the characters' personal journeys.

Comparatively, Winters' work can be likened to the novels of authors like Harlan Coben and Lisa Gardner, who also excel in crafting suspenseful narratives with strong emotional cores. However, Winters distinguishes herself by focusing more intently on the romantic and emotional development of her characters, making When We Were Eighteen a unique blend of romance and suspense.

Overall, When We Were Eighteen is a captivating read that offers a perfect blend of mystery, romance, and emotional depth. Jeannette Winters has crafted a story that not only entertains but also prompts readers to reflect on the nature of family, love, and the choices we make to protect those we care about. The book's ability to engage readers on multiple levels—through its intriguing plot, well-developed characters, and resonant themes—makes it a standout in its genre.

For readers who enjoy stories that combine suspense with heartfelt romance, When We Were Eighteen is a must-read. It is a testament to Winters' ability to create a narrative that is both thrilling and emotionally satisfying, leaving a lasting impact long after the final page is turned.