When She Tempts (The Fallen) by Gabrielle Sands is a riveting foray into the dark, tangled corridors of forbidden love and the complexities of redemption. The novel is a notable addition to the romance genre, especially excelling in its paranormal elements, which imbue the narrative with an irresistible, gothic charm. Sands, known for her eloquent prose and well-crafted characters, does not disappoint in this latest entry in The Fallen series. This review will delve into the elements that make When She Tempts a compelling and emotional rollercoaster.

The novel is centered around Evangeline, a young woman who is part of a hidden world—a society of beings with supernatural powers. These beings, known as the Fallen, live alongside humans but are bound by strict laws to keep their existence secret. Evangeline, innocent yet inherently strong, encounters Gabriel, a mysterious newcomer with a dark past and responsibilities that tie him irrevocably to the world of the Fallen. As their paths cross, the instant chemistry between them sparks a journey filled with danger, forbidden desires, and a series of ethical dilemmas.

Sands' portrayal of Evangeline is particularly noteworthy. She transcends the typical damsel-in-distress archetype often found in paranormal romances. Evangeline's character is beautifully layered; she is resilient, morally grounded, yet filled with curiosity about her dark surroundings. Her relationship with Gabriel is skillfully developed, rooting the reader in their emotional struggles. Gabriel, on the other hand, epitomizes the tortured hero, battling his inner demons and the external forces that threaten to pull him away from his moral anchor—Evangeline. His character development is a strong pillar in the book, enabling readers to empathize with his difficult choices and root for his redemption.

The setting of When She Tempts deserves a separate mention. The dark, moody atmosphere that Sands creates is palpable. Settings ranged from dimly lit, mysterious forests to grand, ancient mansions belonging to the Fallen, each brimming with secrets. The environment is almost a character in itself, reflecting the inner turmoil of the protagonists and amplifying the themes of concealment and forbidden love. This meticulous attention to setting enhances the gothic tone of the story, making the eerie beauty of the world of the Fallen come alive.

The plot of the novel is tightly knit, with twists and surprises that keep the pages turning. The conflicts that arise are not just external threats but internal battles that challenge the characters’ beliefs and aspirations. This internal struggle adds depth to the story, setting it apart from more superficial romantic tales. The pacing is measured, effectively building tension and emotions to the pinnacle, then providing gratifying resolutions that feel natural and well-earned.

Moreover, When She Tempts shines in its thematic depth. The moral questions posed about love, duty, and freedom resonate throughout the novel, engaging the reader's mind as well as their heart. Each character's decisions echo these themes, serving as a mirror to the larger, often universal struggles between heart and responsibility. Sands does not shy away from making her characters face difficult choices, thereby avoiding clichéd resolutions and instead offering more nuanced, thought-provoking endings.

In terms of language and style, Sands’ writing is eloquent and vivid. Her descriptive prowess brings scenes vividly to life, and the dialogue often pierces with its authenticity and emotional honesty. The narrative flows seamlessly, carrying readers along the journey of Evangeline and Gabriel with fluidity that makes their world easily visualizable and deeply felt.

However, no book is without its minor flaws. A few readers might find the initial setup of the world a bit complex, requiring attention to grasp the nuances of the society of the Fallen. Additionally, the romance, while beautifully developed, sometimes takes precedence over other compelling plot elements, which could have been explored further.

In conclusion, When She Tempts (The Fallen) by Gabrielle Sands is a masterful blend of intense romance, moral dilemmas, and a hauntingly beautiful paranormal world. The characters of Evangeline and Gabriel, along with the gripping plot and gothic atmosphere, make this novel a standout. Readers looking for a story that offers both heartache and joy, all while challenging their ethical perspectives, will find this book a rewarding experience. Sands proves once again that she is a formidable force in the genre, crafting stories that linger in the mind and touch the soul.