Adele Clee's What You Propose (Anything for Love 2) is a captivating historical romance that intricately weaves themes of love, loyalty, and redemption against the backdrop of 19th-century England and France. The narrative revolves around two compelling characters: Marie Labelle, a woman with a tumultuous past, and Marcus Danbury, a man caught between duty and desire. Clee's storytelling prowess shines as she explores the complexities of their relationship while addressing broader societal issues of class, gender, and personal agency.

Marie Labelle is introduced as the infamous madam of a high-class brothel, a role that allows her to navigate the treacherous waters of London society while concealing her true self. The blurb hints at her fierce independence and determination to never bow to a man again, a sentiment that resonates throughout the novel. Her character is a rich tapestry of strength and vulnerability, shaped by her past experiences. When she kills the notorious Comte de Dampierre in an act of self-defense, Marie's life takes a dramatic turn, forcing her to seek refuge in an abandoned monastery in France. This pivotal moment sets the stage for her character's evolution as she grapples with her choices and the consequences that follow.

On the other hand, Marcus Danbury is portrayed as a man of honor, albeit one with a complicated lineage as the illegitimate son of an earl. His initial reluctance to provide sanctuary for Marie stems from his disdain for the nobility and the debt he owes to Lord Danesfield. Clee does an excellent job of fleshing out Marcus's internal conflict; he is a man who values loyalty yet finds himself drawn to the very woman he is supposed to protect. This tension between duty and desire is a recurring theme in the novel, and it adds depth to Marcus's character as he navigates his feelings for Marie while fulfilling his obligations.

The chemistry between Marie and Marcus is palpable from their first encounter, particularly highlighted by the moment Marie slaps Marcus in a fit of defiance. This act of rebellion not only establishes her character as fiercely independent but also sets the tone for their tumultuous relationship. Clee skillfully balances their interactions with moments of tension and tenderness, allowing readers to witness the gradual unraveling of their defenses as they confront their pasts and the fears that bind them.

One of the novel's strengths lies in its exploration of the theme of sanctuary—both physical and emotional. Marie seeks refuge from her past mistakes, while Marcus grapples with his own demons and the expectations placed upon him by society. Their relationship evolves into a sanctuary for both characters, as they find solace in each other's company amidst the chaos of their lives. Clee's portrayal of this emotional refuge is poignant, emphasizing the healing power of love and understanding.

Moreover, Clee does not shy away from addressing the societal constraints that define her characters. Marie's position as a madam places her in a precarious position within the rigid class structure of the time, and her struggle for autonomy is a central theme. The author deftly critiques the limitations placed on women, particularly those who defy societal norms. Marie's journey is not just one of romantic entanglement; it is also a quest for self-acceptance and empowerment, making her a relatable and inspiring character.

In terms of pacing, What You Propose maintains a steady rhythm, with well-timed revelations and plot twists that keep readers engaged. Clee's writing is both evocative and accessible, painting vivid imagery of the settings while allowing readers to immerse themselves in the emotional landscape of her characters. The dialogue is sharp and often laced with wit, adding a layer of charm to the interactions between Marie and Marcus.

As the story unfolds, the stakes rise, leading to moments of suspense that heighten the tension between the protagonists. Clee expertly intertwines romance with elements of danger, creating a narrative that is as thrilling as it is romantic. The climax of the story is both satisfying and thought-provoking, leaving readers to ponder the choices made by the characters and the implications of their actions.

In comparison to other historical romances, such as those by authors like Julia Quinn or Lisa Kleypas, Clee's work stands out for its focus on the complexities of character development and the exploration of societal issues. While many romances often follow a predictable formula, Clee's narrative is enriched by its depth and the authenticity of its characters. The emotional stakes feel real, and the resolution is earned rather than contrived, making for a more rewarding reading experience.

Overall, What You Propose is a beautifully crafted tale that resonates with themes of love, loyalty, and the quest for identity. Adele Clee has created a world where her characters grapple with their pasts while forging a future together, making this novel a compelling read for fans of historical romance. With its rich character development and engaging plot, this book is sure to leave a lasting impression on readers, inviting them to reflect on the power of love and the importance of self-discovery.