We Were Together by Amanda Jones is a poignant exploration of the intricacies of shared histories, the enduring impact of past loves, and the complex layers of human connection that challenge the simplicity of the phrase "moving on." Jones, known for her deeply moving and character-driven narratives, delivers yet another compelling story set against the backdrop of rural America, where the landscapes are as vivid as the emotions they evoke.

The novel revolves around the intertwined lives of Ellie, Sam, and Jane, who grew up together in the small town of Harfield. Central to their shared past is a tragedy during their teenage years that profoundly shaped their futures. As adults, their paths converge once more when Ellie returns to Harfield after a decade in New York. Her homecoming is tainted with the task of clearing out her childhood home after her mother's passing, but it also stirs old memories and rekindles past relationships. The narrative unfolds through a series of alternating viewpoints, providing a multi-dimensional perspective on the events that led them to where they are in the present. This narrative structure enriches the reader's understanding of each character’s motivations and the complexities of their actions.

Jones’s portrayal of Ellie is remarkably nuanced. She is depicted as a woman caught between her desire to move forward and the powerful pull of her past. Her relationship with Sam, marked by deep affection and painful distance, forms the backbone of the story. The reader is drawn deeply into their journey, experiencing the tension and tenderness that define their interactions. Jane, as the often-overlooked third in their trio, brings a compelling narrative of her own — one filled with loss, resilience, and the quest for self-identity, which challenges the often superficial judgments made about her in the past.

The author’s use of the rural setting does more than just paint a scenic background; it acts as a canvas for the story, reflecting the internal states of her characters. The expansive fields and closed community of Harfield mirror the open yet constrained lives of Ellie, Sam, and Jane. There’s a palpable sense of place in Jones’s writing that often serves as a metaphor for visibility and invisibility in small-town life, where everyone knows your face but few know your heart.

Aside from the central themes of love and reconciliation, Jones tackles complex social issues with grace and sensitivity. She addresses the stigmas attached to mental health, the socioeconomic divides that influence life choices, and the subtle yet significant impacts of gender expectations within a small community. Each element is woven seamlessly into the fabric of the story, allowing the social commentary to resonate without overpowering the personal narratives of the characters.

The prose throughout the novel is both lyrical and accessible, a testament to Jones’s skill as a writer. Her descriptions are evocative without being overly ornate, and her dialogue captures the natural rhythm of speech, with each character's voice distinct and credible. The pacing is deliberate, with moments of intense action balanced by slower, introspective passages that allow for character development and thematic depth.

However, We Were Together is not without its minor flaws. At times, the detailed backstories can feel overly elaborate, potentially diluting the momentum of the main narrative. Furthermore, the resolution of some of the plot’s conflicts might come across to some readers as too tidy, given the novel's otherwise commendable embrace of the complexities and messiness of human life.

In culmination, Amanda Jones's We Were Together is a heartfelt and thought-provoking novel that deftly examines the enduring effects of past loves and the pains and pleasures of returning home. It’s a story rich with emotion, social insight, and universal truths, rendered with a sensitivity that both respects and challenges its characters. Fans of character-driven fiction and readers looking for a story that combines depth with warmth will find this novel a rewarding read. Despite minor critiques on pacing and conflict resolution, the book stands as a testament to the power of storytelling in navigating the landscapes of human hearts and communal bonds.

Overall, Jones does a superb job of crafting a narrative that is as entrancing as it is meaningful, securing her place as a significant voice in contemporary fiction. Her ability to weave complex characters into the fabric of a well-plotted story reaffirms her literary prowess and ensures that We Were Together will resonate deeply with those who delve into its pages.