Until You by Penelope Douglas is the compelling companion novel to Bully, the first book in the Fall Away series. It revisits the intense and complex relationship between Tate and Jared, but this time from Jared's perspective. This shift in viewpoint offers not only a fresh take on the original plot but also enriches the understanding of the characters’ motivations, especially those of the male protagonist, Jared Trent. Douglas masterfully uses this alternative perspective to delve deeper into the themes of redemption, love, and the pains of growing up.

The narrative brings us back to the small town where Jared and Tate grew up. These two characters have known each other all their lives, but a series of misunderstandings and personal traumas led Jared to unleash a relentless campaign of bullying against Tate, the girl who once was his closest friend. The previous book, centered on Tate's point of view, painted Jared largely as an antagonist. However, Until You peels back the layers of his tough demeanor to expose a confused, hurt young man struggling to cope with his turbulent emotions and the fallouts of a broken home.

One of the strengths of Douglas’s writing is her ability to craft multi-dimensional characters. Jared, previously seen as cruel and domineering, is portrayed with a level of sensitivity and complexity that might surprise those who have only seen him through Tate's eyes. This novel explores the reasons behind his harsh behavior, tracing back to his mother’s abandonment and the resultant hardened attitude he developed as a protective shell. His vulnerabilities are laid bare, and his journey towards self-awareness and change becomes a central theme in the book.

Douglas does not shy away from addressing the darker elements of the story. The psychological depth she brings to the bullying aspect is noteworthy. Rather than simplifying the issue, she explores the cyclical nature of hurt where the oppressed can often become the oppressor. The book prompts readers to consider how past pain, if not properly managed, can lead to destructive behavior towards oneself and others. Through Jared's eyes, readers experience the regret and internal conflict that comes with realizing the impact of one's actions. This adds a moral complexity to the narrative that enriches the overall tale.

The romance between Jared and Tate is, as expected, turbulent but deeply moving. Seeing his love and longing for Tate through his own narrative brings a romantic tension that is both painful and exhilarating. The dynamic between them shifts as Jared undergoes personal growth, from conflict to understanding, and possibly to healing. Douglas excels in portraying a realistic, albeit fraught, path back to trust and mutual respect, making their relationship’s development one of the most compelling aspects of the book.

Aside from the main characters, the secondary characters are also well-developed, providing support and adding layers to the story. Douglas uses them effectively to mirror and contrast with Jared’s personal struggles, enhancing the main storyline and weaving a richer narrative tapestry. The setting of a small town acts almost as another character, reflecting the close-knit yet suffocating environment that shapes the lives of the characters.

Stylistically, Penelope Douglas maintains a brisk pace throughout the novel, which keeps readers engaged from beginning to end. Her prose is clear and emotive, capable of conveying deep sentiments without overcomplication. Dialogue is another strong point, realistic and sharp, it drives the story forward and deepens character relationships without needless exposition.

However, no book is without its potential flaws. Some readers might find the initial premise of redeeming a bully a challenging pill to swallow. The transformation of Jared, though compellingly written, might not be sufficient for some readers to sympathize with him, given the severity of his past actions. Moreover, the intense focus on the protagonists without parallel plot diversions might not appeal to those looking for a broader narrative scope or more intricate plot developments.

In conclusion, Until You is a remarkable effort by Penelope Douglas to humanize a character that many love to hate. It provides a nuanced look into the internal struggles that lead to outward aggression and emphasizes the potential for change in everyone. This novel not only serves as a companion to Bully but stands on its own as a deep, psychologically rich romance that challenges readers to look beyond the surface. Douglas’s skillful handling of sensitive topics and her ability to craft engaging, complex characters make this a standout read for fans of contemporary romance with a darker edge.