"Unsettled" by A.J. Wolf is a novel that immediately draws the reader into a maelstrom of psychological intrigue and shadowy conspiracies, enveloping the reader in a storyline replete with sharp twists and deeply layered characters. The novel revolves around the central character, Claire, whose sudden disappearance and subsequent return causes ripples throughout the narrative, unsettling the lives of everyone around her.

The story is masterfully set in a quaint town, stark and vivid against the foreboding backdrop of sweeping woodlands—a perfect canvas for a tale that treads the lines between paranoia, supernatural elements, and taut psychological drama. Wolf’s skilled use of the setting amplifies the suspense, making the scenic quietude of the town itself a hauntingly silent witness to the unfolding drama.

From the very beginning, Wolf ensnares the imagination of readers with a striking balance between suspense and detailed character exploration. Claire is presented not merely as a woman grappling with the aftermath of her elusive ordeal, but as a complex persona, whose relationships and perceptions shape the very core of the narrative. The way Wolf peels back the layers of Claire’s psyche, while simultaneously advancing the plot, is nothing short of brilliant.

The supporting cast members are equally compelling. Each character introduced by Wolf is meticulously crafted, with backstories and motivations that weave intricately into the main storyline. Whether it’s Claire’s long-suffering husband, her skeptic mother, or her eerie neighbor, each person enriches the story, providing broader social and psychological insights. Perhaps most fascinating is how their interactions with Claire open a Pandora’s box of questions about trust, reality, and the human psyche.

Wolf’s writing style is another element that stands out. The prose is crisp, laden with a moodiness that perfectly matches the evolving mystery. Descriptive yet concise, each sentence is crafted to push the narrative forward, while also allowing room for the reader’s interpretation—an essential feature in psychological thrillers. The dialogue, sharp and realistically written, entrenches readers deeper into the characters’ psyche, effectively revealing their innermost fears and desires.

Symbolism is wielded like a tool throughout "Unsettled". Wolf uses symbolic elements, from the oppressive wilderness surrounding the town to the disquieting calm of the lake near Claire’s home, to mirror the inner turmoil of the characters. These symbols are not just scenic descriptions but are pivotal to understanding the thematic essence of the novel— the exploration of unsettlement in its myriad forms, be it mental, emotional, or environmental.

This thematic exploration of unsettlement is perhaps what makes Wolf’s novel so captivating. The elements of the supernatural and the psychological are blended seamlessly, raising questions about the limits of human understanding and the deep-seated fear of the unknown. As the plot progresses, the lines between reality and paranoia blur, a testament to Wolf's prowess in manipulating reader expectations and emotions.

However, no novel is without its flaws. At certain junctures, the pacing seems uneven—the buildup sometimes gives way to rushed climaxes that, though effective in their surprise, seem slightly out of step with the meticulously crafted build-up. Additionally, while most of the characters are well-rounded, a few secondary characters could have benefitted from more depth or a more substantial arc to match the complex interplay established among the main characters.

In conclusion, "Unsettled" by A.J. Wolf is a profound journey into the dark corridors of human psychology dressed in the garb of a thriller. It combines smart plot twists, well-developed characters, and profound thematic explorations to challenge and entertain its readers. The novel is a commendable feat, especially in how it molds the elements of traditional thriller genres to offer something that is not only thought-provoking but deeply resonant. Fans of psychological thrillers seeking a tale that ventures beyond mere narrative to pose significant questions about reality, perception, and fear will find "Unsettled" a worthwhile and compelling read. A.J. Wolf has penned a hauntingly beautiful narrative that sticks with the reader long after the last page is turned.