A.W. Scott's Tutoring Mr. Hotshot is a delightful foray into the world of college romance, where the unlikely pairing of a bookish academic and a rugged hockey player unfolds into a heartwarming narrative. The book is part of the Daddies of the League series, which explores the dynamics of relationships within the context of college ice hockey. Scott's novel is a refreshing take on the enemies-to-lovers trope, infused with themes of personal growth, acceptance, and the power of found family.

At the heart of the story is Rodney, a brilliant college student who is deeply invested in his academic pursuits. Rodney's character is meticulously crafted, embodying the quintessential intellectual who has been scarred by past experiences with athletes. His initial disdain for hockey players is rooted in a history of bullying, making his reluctance to engage with Andry, the foreign exchange student and hockey player, entirely understandable. Scott does an excellent job of portraying Rodney's internal conflict, as he grapples with his preconceived notions and the undeniable attraction he feels towards Andry.

Andry, on the other hand, is the embodiment of the classic athlete with a twist. While he is focused on his goal of joining a professional hockey team, his character is enriched by his unexpected vulnerability and genuine interest in Rodney. Andry's persistence in pursuing Rodney is both endearing and refreshing, as it challenges the typical jock stereotype. His character development is one of the highlights of the novel, as he learns to balance his ambitions with his growing affection for Rodney.

The chemistry between Rodney and Andry is palpable from their first encounter. Scott skillfully builds their relationship, moving from initial animosity to a deep, meaningful connection. The progression of their romance is both natural and engaging, with moments of tension and tenderness that keep the reader invested. The author’s ability to weave humor and warmth into their interactions adds a layer of authenticity to their relationship.

One of the standout themes in Tutoring Mr. Hotshot is the concept of taking back power from those who feel entitled to control others. This theme is explored through the challenges Rodney and Andry face from Andry's teammates, who attempt to interfere in their relationship. The narrative highlights the importance of standing up for oneself and the strength found in supportive relationships. This is further emphasized by the presence of a strong found family, which provides both characters with the love and support they need to overcome external pressures.

Scott also delves into the dynamics of a "Daddy" relationship, a recurring motif in the Daddies of the League series. Andry's desire to care for and spoil Rodney adds an interesting dimension to their relationship, exploring themes of protection, nurturing, and mutual respect. This aspect of their relationship is handled with sensitivity and care, ensuring that it enhances rather than overshadows the central romance.

The novel is rich with secondary characters who add depth and vibrancy to the story. From supportive friends to delightful relatives, these characters contribute to the sense of community and belonging that permeates the narrative. Scott's portrayal of these relationships underscores the importance of having a network of supportive individuals who can provide guidance and encouragement.

In terms of writing style, Scott excels in creating vivid imagery and crafting dialogue that feels both natural and engaging. The pacing of the novel is well-balanced, allowing for moments of introspection and character development alongside the unfolding romance. The author’s ability to blend humor, emotion, and romance results in a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking.

When compared to other works in the genre, such as Sarina Bowen's Him series or Elle Kennedy's Off-Campus series, Tutoring Mr. Hotshot holds its own with its unique blend of romance and personal growth. While Bowen and Kennedy focus heavily on the sports aspect, Scott's novel places a greater emphasis on the emotional journey of the characters, making it a standout in the realm of sports romance.

Overall, Tutoring Mr. Hotshot is a captivating read that offers a fresh perspective on the college romance genre. A.W. Scott has crafted a story that is both heartwarming and empowering, with characters that resonate long after the final page. For readers seeking a romance that combines humor, heart, and a touch of drama, this novel is a must-read. Whether you're a fan of sports romances or simply enjoy a well-told love story, Tutoring Mr. Hotshot is sure to leave a lasting impression.