Katie Ashley's Three Pucks and a Baby is a delightful romp through the unexpected twists and turns of modern romance, set against the backdrop of a college campus. The novel is a refreshing take on the romantic comedy genre, blending humor, passion, and the complexities of unconventional relationships. At its core, the book explores themes of self-discovery, love, and the unpredictable nature of life’s curveballs.

The protagonist, Vivian, is a relatable and endearing character. As a university librarian, she embodies the quintessential image of a woman who is both intelligent and reserved, yet yearning for something more than her routine life. Her character development is one of the novel’s strongest points. As she approaches her thirtieth birthday, Vivian is at a crossroads, seeking an adventure that will break the monotony of her life. Her journey from a quiet librarian to a woman who embraces the chaos of love and unexpected motherhood is both humorous and heartwarming.

The inciting incident of the novel—a chance encounter with a hockey player in the library—sets the stage for a series of events that are as unpredictable as they are entertaining. The proposal of a birthday threesome, which quickly evolves into a quadsome, is handled with a light touch and a sense of humor that keeps the reader engaged. Ashley’s writing shines in these moments, capturing the awkwardness and excitement of Vivian’s foray into uncharted territory.

What sets Three Pucks and a Baby apart from other romantic comedies is its exploration of non-traditional relationships. The addition of a bi-curious roommate adds depth to the story, challenging the characters and the readers to reconsider conventional notions of love and partnership. The dynamics between Vivian and the three hockey players are complex and well-developed, each character bringing their own unique personality and charm to the narrative.

The three potential baby daddies—each vying for Vivian’s affection—are more than just stereotypical jocks. Ashley gives each character depth and dimension, allowing the reader to see beyond their initial appearances. Their interactions with Vivian are filled with humor, tenderness, and genuine emotion, making the reader invested in the outcome of the genetic test that will determine the father of Vivian’s baby.

One of the novel’s most compelling themes is the idea that love does not always conform to traditional molds. Vivian’s journey is a testament to the fact that relationships can be as unique and varied as the individuals involved. The novel challenges societal norms and encourages readers to embrace the idea that love can be found in unexpected places and forms.

In terms of writing style, Katie Ashley’s prose is engaging and accessible. Her ability to balance humor with heartfelt moments is commendable, making Three Pucks and a Baby a page-turner from start to finish. The dialogue is witty and realistic, capturing the essence of each character and their relationships with one another.

Comparatively, fans of authors like Christina Lauren and Sally Thorne will find much to enjoy in Ashley’s work. Like Lauren’s Roomies or Thorne’s The Hating Game, Three Pucks and a Baby offers a fresh take on romance, filled with laughter, love, and a touch of the unexpected. However, Ashley’s novel stands out for its bold exploration of polyamorous relationships and the challenges and joys they bring.

Overall, Three Pucks and a Baby is a delightful read that will appeal to fans of romantic comedies and those looking for a story that breaks away from traditional romance tropes. It’s a novel that celebrates the messiness of life and love, reminding us that sometimes the most unconventional paths lead to the most rewarding destinations.

In conclusion, Katie Ashley has crafted a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, with characters that linger in the reader’s mind long after the final page. Three Pucks and a Baby is a testament to the power of love in all its forms and a reminder that life’s greatest adventures often begin with a single, unexpected moment.