Grace Burrowes’ The Trouble With Dukes is a delightful foray into the world of Regency romance, where societal expectations and personal desires often clash in the most intriguing ways. This novel, the first in the Windham Brides series, introduces readers to a compelling narrative that combines romance, humor, and a touch of mystery, all set against the backdrop of London’s high society.

At the heart of the story is Hamish MacHugh, the newly minted Duke of Murdoch, who is burdened with a fearsome reputation. Known as the "duke of murder," Hamish is rumored to be a brute and a murderer, a reputation exacerbated by his Scottish heritage, which adds an exotic and somewhat dangerous allure to his character. However, Burrowes skillfully peels back the layers of this seemingly intimidating figure to reveal a man of depth and vulnerability. Hamish is a character who is not only grappling with the expectations of his new title but also with the scars of war, making him a richly developed and sympathetic protagonist.

In contrast, Megan Windham is a breath of fresh air. She is not intimidated by Hamish’s dark reputation; instead, she sees beyond the rumors to the man beneath. Megan’s character is a testament to Burrowes’ ability to craft strong, intelligent female leads who are not afraid to defy societal norms. Her willingness to engage with Hamish on a personal level, teaching him to waltz and helping him navigate the complexities of a London Season, showcases her strength and independence. Megan’s own struggles, hinted at throughout the novel, add an additional layer of complexity to her character, making her a perfect match for Hamish.

The chemistry between Hamish and Megan is palpable from their first meeting. Burrowes excels in creating romantic tension that is both believable and engaging. Their relationship develops organically, with moments of humor and tenderness that are sure to captivate readers. The waltz lessons, in particular, serve as a metaphor for their growing intimacy, with each step bringing them closer together both physically and emotionally.

One of the novel’s standout themes is the idea of reputation versus reality. Hamish’s struggle with his fearsome reputation highlights the often-unfair judgments society places on individuals based on hearsay and prejudice. Burrowes uses this theme to explore deeper issues of identity and self-worth, as Hamish learns to reconcile his past with his present. Similarly, Megan’s own battles with societal expectations underscore the pressures faced by women during the Regency era, adding depth and relevance to her character.

Burrowes’ writing is both elegant and accessible, capturing the nuances of Regency society with a keen eye for detail. Her descriptions of the London Season, with its balls and social gatherings, provide a vivid backdrop for the unfolding romance. The dialogue is sharp and witty, with moments of humor that lighten the narrative and endear the characters to the reader.

In comparison to other Regency romances, such as Julia Quinn’s Bridgerton series or Lisa Kleypas’ Wallflowers series, The Trouble With Dukes holds its own with its unique blend of romance and character-driven storytelling. While Quinn often focuses on the broader dynamics of family and society, and Kleypas delves into the intricacies of personal relationships, Burrowes strikes a balance between the two, offering a story that is both intimate and expansive.

Overall, The Trouble With Dukes is a captivating start to the Windham Brides series. Grace Burrowes has crafted a romance that is as heartwarming as it is thought-provoking, with characters that linger in the mind long after the final page is turned. For fans of Regency romance, this novel is a must-read, offering a fresh perspective on the genre while staying true to its beloved conventions. Whether you are a longtime fan of Burrowes or new to her work, this book promises a satisfying and memorable reading experience.