Taking Orders in the Underworld, penned by Gwyneth Lesley, is a captivating blend of dark fantasy and romance, set against an atmospheric underworld realm. This novel marks Lesley’s foray into dark literary alleys, divergent from her previous, lighter works, exploring themes of power, redemption, and love in a landscape brimming with the supernatural and existential dread. Lesley's narrative is as intoxicating as the world she crafts, drawing readers into a universe that is as unsettling as it is alluring.

The plot unfolds following the journey of Eris, a young woman who unexpectedly finds herself in the thriving heart of a shadowy netherworld. Here, she must navigate a labyrinth of intrigue and resist the temptations of power as she serves the enigmatic and seemingly heartless Lord Malachite. Eris, a character both strong-willed and vulnerable, initially appears as a mere pawn in an elaborately set underworld game. However, Lesley skillfully escalates Eris from a sidelined newcomer to a central player. Her evolution from a desperate soul looking to escape her mundane existence to an influential figure in the underworld is crafted with meticulous character development and depth.

Lord Malachite, on the other hand, epitomizes the anti-hero archetype. Lesley dives deep into his psyche, revealing layers of complexity that challenge the reader’s initial perceptions. This enigmatic character is both a captor and a mentor to Eris, embodying the tensions that drive the narrative forward. His interactions with Eris range from cold dominance to surprising tenderness, creating a dynamic that is as unpredictable as it is fascinating. The chemistry between Eris and Malachite unfolds with a simmering intensity, which Lesley manages to maintain throughout the novel, keeping the readers on the edge of their seats.

Lesley’s underworld is a masterpiece of world-building. From the eerie luminescence of the cavern lights to the bustling marketplaces trading in both mundane and spectral goods, the settings in Taking Orders in the Underworld are vividly imagined and richly detailed. The author’s description of the landscapes and interiors resonates with a Gothic charm that perfectly complements the dark themes of the story. Each setting is not merely a backdrop but an active participant in the narrative, influencing the characters and the unfolding drama.

The novel also excels in its exploration of thematic depth. Questions of morality and freedom permeate the pages, as Eris grapples with the realization that every choice in the underworld carries weight and consequences. The philosophical underpinnings of the underworld’s society, where order and chaos are in constant negotiation, provide a fertile ground for exploring these themes. Lesley does not shy away from addressing the darker aspects of control and manipulation, making the narrative not only thrilling but also intellectually stimulating.

However, the pacing of the story sometimes wavers. Certain sections of the book, especially in the middle parts where the initial thrill of the underworld starts to wane, feel somewhat prolonged. Yet, Lesley manages to pull back the momentum with surprising plot twists and revelations that realign the reader’s engagement with the narrative arc.

The language used by Lesley is another highlight. Her prose is both elegant and sharp, with a lyrical quality that enhances the mythical feel of the book. Dialogues are crafted with precision, often carrying overt and covert meanings that reveal more with each read. This attention to detail in language not only enriches the storytelling but also deepens the reader’s immersion into the underworld’s enigmatic ambience.

Supporting characters like the wise yet cryptic Oracle and the fiercely loyal yet conflicted Sentinel add richness to the plot, providing multiple viewpoints on the events unfolding within the underworld. Their interactions with Eris help paint a broader picture of the underworld’s society and politics, which is crucial in understanding her journey and transformations.

In conclusion, Taking Orders in the Underworld by Gwyneth Lesley is a compelling dark fantasy that skillfully interweaves elements of romance, intrigue, and moral complexity. Despite some pacing issues, the vivid world-building, engaging plot, and deeply layered characters make this novel a standout. Lesley has crafted an entrancing narrative that not only entertains but also provokes thought, making it a must-read for fans of the genre and beyond. It is a testament to her evolution as a writer and her ability to enchant and engage her audience with profoundly imaginative tales.