Since the Day We Wished, authored by Kerk Murray, is a poignant exploration of destiny, choice, and the interplay between the two. Through its intricate narrative and deep character development, the novel invites readers into a meticulously crafted world where wishes aren't just whimsical desires, but powerful forces capable of altering reality. Murray's latest work stands as both a narrative delight and an insightful commentary on the nature of desires and consequences.

The novel centers around the lives of two main characters, Elara and Jasper, whose fates become intertwined following a series of wish-induced events commencing on New Year's Eve. This night, significant within the narrative, utilizes an ancient comet passing overhead which is believed to possess the power to grant wishes made at midnight. Elara, hopeful and despairing, wishes for a new beginning away from her tumultuous past; Jasper, a cynic of fate, wishes spitefully for evidence that destiny can be manipulated. This convergence of desires sets them on a collision course that defies the simple logic of cause and effect.

Murray’s storytelling prowess shines through in his ability to weave complex scenarios that challenge his characters’ and readers' perceptions of free will. The prose is lyrical yet accessible, making profound observations without pretension. The dialogue between Elara and Jasper crackles with intensity, offering a layered understanding of their evolving thoughts and emotions. As the chapters alternate perspectives between Elara and Jasper, Murray expertly balances their personal growth with the progressing story, giving a comprehensive insight into their psychological and emotional states.

One of the standout elements of Since the Day We Wished is its deep dive into the ethical implications of wish fulfillment. The novel doesn’t shy away from the darker sides of its central premise. For every wish that brings joy, there is one that brings unforeseen repercussions. This duality is encapsulated in the supporting characters, such as Miriam, Elara's elderly neighbor whose wish for her husband’s return from the grave comes with heartrending consequences, and Finn, Jasper’s brother, whose trivial wish sets off a catastrophic chain of events. These stories enrich the main narrative, providing a broader spectrum of outcomes and emphasizing the novel’s central theme: that every choice, every wish, has weight.

The setting of the novel—a small, seemingly idyllic town with an undercurrent of ancient and mystical energies—is another character in its own right. Murray's detailed descriptions of the scenic landscapes, the historical architecture, and the tempestuous weather patterns contribute to an atmospheric backdrop that complements the story’s emotional depth. The mystical elements, though prominent, are presented in a manner that feels natural, enhancing the realism of the narrative despite its fantastical components.

Murray does not simply write a novel; he crafts a philosophical inquiry draped in the elegance of fiction. The interplay of light and dark, the examination of destiny versus self-determination, and the poignant explorations of hope and despair are profound. However, the climax of the novel, where all threads converge, feels slightly rushed, leaving a few questions lingering perhaps a bit too conspicuously. Despite these pacing issues, the resolution is satisfying, bringing a thoughtful conclusion to the turbulent journeys of Elara and Jasper.

Moreover, Murray’s ability to describe complex emotional states with clarity and empathy is commendable. There are passages in the book that resonate deeply, often leaving the reader pausing to reflect on their own life choices and wishes. This reflective quality is what elevates Since the Day We Wished from being merely a novel to being a mirror held up against the nature of human desires.

Overall, Since the Day We Wished by Kerk Murray is a multi-layered, engaging tale that successfully blends elements of fantasy with deep human truths. It is a book for those who enjoy thoughtful, character-driven stories that prompt introspection. While the narrative may occasionally stumble under its ambitious thematic weight, it remains a compelling read that richly rewards its audience.