Scarlett Philips' novel, Returning to Everton, is a poignant exploration of loss, redemption, and the enduring power of friendship. The story centers around a thirty-year-old widow, grappling with the unexpected turns her life has taken. With a five-year-old daughter in tow, she decides to return to her hometown of Everton, a place filled with memories and unresolved relationships.

The protagonist's journey is both heart-wrenching and hopeful. Her initial vision of life—a quaint existence running a bakery and raising a family in her beloved hometown—has been shattered by the untimely death of her husband. This sets the stage for a narrative that delves deeply into themes of grief, resilience, and the quest for belonging.

One of the novel's most compelling aspects is its exploration of the protagonist's internal struggle. For the past decade, she has been unable to use her magic, a metaphor for the suppression of her true self and desires. This magical element adds a layer of complexity to the story, symbolizing the protagonist's need to reclaim her identity and autonomy. Philips uses magic not as a fantastical escape but as a tool for introspection and personal growth.

The decision to return to Everton is fraught with uncertainty. The protagonist's departure from the town was marked by unresolved conflicts with her four best male friends and her best friend, Quinn. This tension forms the emotional core of the narrative, as she grapples with the fear of rejection and the hope for reconciliation. Philips skillfully navigates these dynamics, creating a rich tapestry of relationships that feel authentic and relatable.

Character development is one of the novel's strengths. The protagonist is portrayed with depth and nuance, her vulnerabilities laid bare as she confronts her past. Her interactions with her daughter are particularly touching, capturing the delicate balance of being a parent while dealing with personal grief. The daughter, though young, is depicted with a maturity that adds depth to their relationship, serving as a catalyst for the protagonist's transformation.

The supporting characters, especially the protagonist's friends, are well-drawn and contribute significantly to the story's emotional impact. Each friend represents a different facet of the protagonist's past and potential future, offering her both challenges and support. Philips excels in portraying the complexities of friendship, highlighting how time and distance can strain bonds but also how shared history can pave the way for healing.

Philips' writing is evocative, capturing the essence of small-town life with its close-knit community and the weight of shared memories. The town of Everton itself becomes a character, its streets and landmarks imbued with nostalgia and significance. This setting provides a backdrop for the protagonist's journey, reinforcing the themes of homecoming and self-discovery.

In comparison to other works in the genre, Returning to Everton stands out for its blend of magical realism and emotional depth. It shares thematic similarities with novels like Sarah Addison Allen's Garden Spells, where magic is intertwined with everyday life, enhancing the narrative without overshadowing the characters' personal journeys. However, Philips' focus on the protagonist's internal conflict and the dynamics of friendship gives her novel a unique voice.

The novel's pacing is deliberate, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the protagonist's world. Philips takes her time to unravel the layers of her characters' emotions, ensuring that their growth feels earned and authentic. This approach may not appeal to readers seeking fast-paced action, but for those who appreciate character-driven stories, it is a rewarding experience.

Overall, Returning to Everton is a beautifully crafted tale of loss and renewal. Scarlett Philips has created a narrative that resonates with anyone who has ever felt the pull of home and the desire to reconcile with their past. The novel's exploration of grief, friendship, and the courage to embrace one's true self is both moving and inspiring. It is a testament to the power of storytelling to heal and transform, making it a must-read for fans of contemporary fiction with a touch of magic.