Caroline Lee's Plaid Attitude is a captivating exploration of love, duty, and the complexities of leadership set against the backdrop of a Scottish clan. This novel deftly combines historical romance with a nuanced portrayal of gender roles and societal expectations, making it a compelling read for fans of the genre.

At the heart of the story is Lady Coira, a character who defies the traditional constraints placed upon women in her time. As the eldest daughter of the eccentric Laird Oliphant, Coira is a woman of ambition and capability. She has long overseen the clan's affairs, demonstrating a keen understanding of leadership and responsibility. However, her aspirations are thwarted by the simple fact that she lacks the "manly bits" required to become the clan's laird. This central conflict is not only a personal struggle for Coira but also a commentary on the gender dynamics of the era. Lee skillfully uses Coira's character to challenge these norms, creating a protagonist who is both relatable and inspiring.

Opposite Coira is Doughall Moray, the clan's commander. Doughall is a man of few words, yet his actions speak volumes. His respect for Coira's abilities is evident, and his internal struggle between admiration and desire adds depth to his character. The dynamic between Coira and Doughall is one of the novel's highlights. Their relationship evolves from professional respect to a deeper, more personal connection, driven by their shared concern for Doughall's daughter, Bess.

Bess is a delightful addition to the story, bringing a youthful energy and innocence that contrasts with the more serious themes. Her friendship with Coira serves as a catalyst for the events that unfold, and her predicament forces Coira and Doughall to confront their feelings and priorities. The bond between Coira and Bess is beautifully portrayed, highlighting Coira's nurturing side and her capacity for love beyond her duties to the clan.

As the plot progresses, the illness of Laird Oliphant adds urgency to Coira's dilemma. The impending decision regarding the clan's leadership forces her to weigh her loyalty to her family against her growing affection for Doughall and Bess. This internal conflict is handled with sensitivity and realism, making Coira's eventual choice both satisfying and thought-provoking.

Lee's writing is both engaging and evocative, capturing the rugged beauty of the Scottish landscape and the intricacies of clan life. Her attention to detail and historical accuracy lend authenticity to the narrative, immersing readers in the world she has created. The dialogue is sharp and often laced with humor, providing moments of levity amidst the tension.

In terms of themes, Plaid Attitude explores the balance between personal desires and communal responsibilities. Coira's journey is one of self-discovery, as she learns to reconcile her ambitions with her capacity for love and compassion. The novel also delves into the idea of leadership and what it truly means to be a leader. Through Coira and Doughall, Lee examines the qualities that make an effective leader, such as empathy, strength, and the ability to inspire others.

Comparatively, Plaid Attitude shares thematic similarities with other historical romances, such as Diana Gabaldon's Outlander series, which also features strong female protagonists navigating the challenges of their time. However, Lee's novel stands out for its focus on gender roles and the unique challenges faced by women in positions of power. The character-driven narrative and the emphasis on personal growth set it apart from more plot-driven romances.

Overall, Plaid Attitude is a richly layered novel that offers more than just a love story. It is a thoughtful exploration of identity, duty, and the courage to defy societal expectations. Caroline Lee has crafted a tale that is both entertaining and enlightening, appealing to readers who appreciate historical romance with depth and substance. Whether you're drawn to the romance, the historical setting, or the themes of empowerment, this book is sure to leave a lasting impression.

In conclusion, Plaid Attitude is a testament to Caroline Lee's skill as a storyteller. Her ability to weave together complex characters, engaging plotlines, and meaningful themes results in a novel that resonates on multiple levels. For those seeking a romance that challenges conventions and celebrates the strength of its characters, this book is a must-read.