Carly Spade's Of Magic and Rum is a captivating blend of fantasy and historical fiction that transports readers into a world where myth and reality intertwine seamlessly. The novel's premise is intriguing, drawing upon the rich lore of Atlantis and the age of piracy to create a narrative that is both adventurous and deeply personal. At its core, the book explores themes of identity, freedom, and the transformative power of love, all set against the backdrop of the high seas.

The protagonist, Rhode, is a sea nymph from the legendary city of Atlantis. Her journey begins with an unexpected twist of fate that propels her into a different time and place, far removed from her aquatic home. This displacement sets the stage for a compelling exploration of identity and belonging. Rhode's struggle to conceal her true nature from the mortals around her is a poignant reflection of the universal human experience of feeling out of place. Her character is richly developed, with Spade skillfully balancing her mystical origins with relatable human emotions.

Rhode's plan to return to her realm is fraught with challenges, not least of which is her decision to disguise herself as a cabin boy aboard a pirate ship. This choice introduces a fascinating dynamic as she navigates the complexities of life at sea, all while maintaining her secret. The tension between her need to survive and her desire to return home is palpable, driving the narrative forward with a sense of urgency and suspense.

Enter Captain Calico Jack Rackham, a character who embodies the quintessential pirate archetype with a twist. Known for his harsh yet fair leadership, Jack is a man of contradictions. His initial interactions with Rhode are marked by suspicion and intrigue, setting the stage for a relationship that evolves in unexpected ways. Spade does an excellent job of developing Jack's character, revealing layers of complexity that make him more than just a stereotypical pirate. His journey from self-serving captain to a man capable of deep devotion is one of the novel's most compelling arcs.

The chemistry between Rhode and Jack is electric, and their evolving relationship is a testament to Spade's ability to craft believable and engaging romantic dynamics. What begins as a strategic alliance quickly becomes something more profound, as both characters are forced to confront their own desires and vulnerabilities. The romance is woven seamlessly into the larger narrative, enhancing the stakes and adding emotional depth to the story.

One of the novel's standout features is its vivid world-building. Spade's depiction of the pirate world is immersive and richly detailed, from the bustling ports to the creaking decks of The Revenge. The inclusion of mythical elements, such as the sea monster that threatens Rhode's journey, adds an extra layer of intrigue and excitement. The blending of historical and fantastical elements is handled with finesse, creating a setting that feels both authentic and magical.

Thematically, Of Magic and Rum delves into the concept of freedom, both physical and emotional. Rhode's quest to return to Atlantis is not just a journey home, but a search for autonomy and self-discovery. Similarly, Jack's transformation is tied to his realization that true freedom comes from embracing vulnerability and connection. These themes are explored with nuance and depth, making the novel resonate on a personal level.

In comparison to other works in the genre, Of Magic and Rum stands out for its unique blend of myth and history. Fans of Naomi Novik's Temeraire series or Susanna Clarke's Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell will appreciate Spade's ability to weave fantastical elements into a historical setting. However, Spade's focus on character-driven storytelling and romance sets her work apart, offering a fresh take on familiar tropes.

Overall, Carly Spade's Of Magic and Rum is a spellbinding tale that will captivate readers with its rich characters, thrilling adventure, and poignant themes. It is a story that invites readers to lose themselves in a world where magic and reality coexist, and where love has the power to transcend even the greatest of obstacles. Whether you're a fan of fantasy, romance, or historical fiction, this novel offers something for everyone, making it a must-read for anyone seeking an escape into a world of wonder and enchantment.