(Not So) Mad About You by Sienna Waters is a romantic comedy that delves into the complexities of modern relationships, old friendships, and the unpredictable path of finding true love. Set in a charming small town, the novel's approach to romance is both heartwarming and whimsical, making it a delightful read for those who enjoy tales that both entertain and provoke thought on personal relationships.

The story revolves around the protagonist, Harper, who is returning to her hometown after a failed relationship and a career that seems just as shaky. The return is fraught with fears of judgment and the dread of confronting her past, especially her high school crush, Riley. Riley, who is now a successful business owner in Harper’s hometown, adds a twist to the story, embodying both the familiar and the changed. The chemistry between them is palpable but complicated by their shared history and Harper's recent romantic disasters.

Sienna Waters excels in character development. Harper is a relatable character whose internal monologues often reflect the concerns and humorous quandaries typical to a thirty-something facing life’s unplanned turns. Through Harper, Waters explores themes of self-doubt, resilience, and the quest for happiness, making the character's journey not only riveting but also inspiring. Riley, on the other hand, is more than just a love interest. Her character is layered, and her interactions with Harper offer insights into how people can grow both apart and together over time.

The secondary characters also add a rich layer to the narrative, enhancing the story's dynamics and providing both comic relief and emotional support to the protagonist. From Harper’s eccentric family members to her supportive group of old friends, each character weaves seamlessly into the main storyline while contributing their unique perspectives and humor.

The dialogues in (Not So) Mad About You are sharp and witty, capturing the essence of each character beautifully. Waters uses dialogue not only as a tool for character development but also as a mechanism to advance the plot, which she does with an expert touch. The interactions between Harper and Riley are especially compelling, filled with a tension and tenderness that keep the readers hooked.

In terms of plot, the novel may follow some predictable paths commonly found in romance comedies, but it is the execution that stands out. The twists are well-timed, and the pacing is brisk, making it a page-turner. Additionally, Waters does a commendable job of painting the small-town setting in vivid hues, giving readers a strong sense of place, which adds an extra layer of authenticity and charm to the tale.

The themes of forgiveness, second chances, and the courage to embrace one’s true self are explored in depth, giving the novel a philosophical edge. Waters does not shy away from pushing her characters into deep, reflective corners, which prompts them—and the reader—to ponder life’s larger questions. This makes (Not So) Mad About You more than just a simple love story; it’s a reflective journey into personal growth and finding joy in unexpected places.

The novel also addresses contemporary issues subtly interwoven through the personal lives of the characters, such as the pressures of social media, the fear of failure, and the importance of self-love. These undercurrents make the story resonate with a modern audience and provide a fuller, more rounded reading experience.

Overall, (Not So) Mad About You is a compelling read that balances humor with gravity, and romance with profound life lessons. Sienna Waters has crafted a story that is as entertaining as it is thoughtful, with characters that linger in your thoughts long after the last page is turned. Whether you are a fan of romantic comedies or new to the genre, this novel promises enjoyment and enlightenment, making it a must-read for those who cherish stories of love, laughter, and self-discovery.