Catherine Mack’s No One Was Supposed to Die at This Wedding is a delightful blend of mystery, romance, and a touch of humor, set against the backdrop of a glamorous wedding on Catalina Island. This novel, which is part of the Vacation Mysteries series, follows Eleanor Dash, a bestselling author who seems to have a knack for stumbling upon murder mysteries wherever she goes. The book is an engaging read that keeps you guessing until the very end, with a cast of well-developed characters and a plot that twists and turns like a winding road.

At the heart of the story is Eleanor Dash, a character who is both relatable and intriguing. As a successful author, Eleanor is used to crafting mysteries, but she finds herself in the middle of one when her best friend, Emma Wood, receives a threatening note on the eve of her wedding. Eleanor’s character is well-rounded, with a sharp wit and a keen sense of observation that makes her the perfect amateur sleuth. Her internal monologue is both humorous and insightful, providing readers with a window into her thoughts as she navigates the complexities of friendship, love, and danger.

The relationship between Eleanor and Emma is a central theme in the novel. Their friendship, which has endured since childhood, is portrayed with warmth and authenticity. Emma, a rising star in Hollywood, is both glamorous and grounded, and her relationship with Eleanor is one of mutual support and understanding. The dynamic between the two women adds depth to the story, as Eleanor is driven not only by the need to solve the mystery but also by her desire to protect her friend.

The setting of Catalina Island adds an atmospheric layer to the narrative. The island, with its picturesque views and isolated location, becomes a character in its own right. The impending storm serves as a metaphor for the chaos that unfolds, heightening the tension and creating a sense of urgency. Mack’s descriptive writing brings the island to life, making readers feel as though they are right there with the characters, experiencing the beauty and the danger of the setting.

The plot of No One Was Supposed to Die at This Wedding is intricately woven, with enough red herrings and plot twists to keep even the most seasoned mystery readers on their toes. The note threatening a murder at the wedding sets off a chain of events that are both thrilling and unpredictable. Mack skillfully balances the elements of mystery and romance, ensuring that neither overshadows the other. The romantic subplot, involving Eleanor’s complicated feelings for her ex, Connor Smith, adds an additional layer of intrigue and emotional depth to the story.

One of the strengths of the novel is its ensemble cast of characters. Each character is distinct and memorable, from the charming yet enigmatic Fred Winters to the various members of the wedding party. Mack does an excellent job of fleshing out these characters, giving each of them motives and secrets that add to the complexity of the mystery. The interactions between the characters are well-written, with dialogue that feels natural and engaging.

In terms of themes, the novel explores the idea of appearances versus reality. Many of the characters are not what they seem, and Eleanor must navigate a web of lies and deceit to uncover the truth. This theme is mirrored in the setting of Hollywood, where image is everything, and the line between fiction and reality is often blurred. The novel also touches on the theme of love and loyalty, as Eleanor’s determination to protect her friend is a driving force in the story.

Comparatively, Mack’s work can be likened to the cozy mysteries of Agatha Christie, where a seemingly idyllic setting is disrupted by murder, and an amateur detective must piece together the clues. However, Mack’s modern twist, with its blend of humor and romance, sets it apart from traditional mysteries. Fans of authors like Janet Evanovich and Meg Cabot will likely find Mack’s style appealing, as it combines elements of mystery, romance, and comedy in a way that is both entertaining and satisfying.

Overall, No One Was Supposed to Die at This Wedding is a captivating read that offers a perfect escape into a world of glamour, intrigue, and romance. Catherine Mack has crafted a story that is both fun and suspenseful, with a heroine who is as endearing as she is clever. Whether you are a fan of mystery, romance, or simply a well-told story, this book is sure to delight and entertain. It’s a testament to Mack’s skill as a storyteller that she can weave together these elements so seamlessly, creating a novel that is as engaging as it is enjoyable.