Camilla Evergreen’s Marrying the Gardener is a delightful romp through the world of marriage of convenience, set against the backdrop of a small town in Sunset, West Virginia. This novel artfully combines humor, romance, and social commentary, making it a compelling read for fans of romantic comedies that offer more than just a love story.

At the heart of the novel is a protagonist who is both relatable and refreshingly complex. The unnamed female lead, who has grown up in a patriarchal environment that undervalues women, is a character many readers will find themselves rooting for. Her journey from playing the "incompetent princess" to taking control of her destiny is both inspiring and thought-provoking. This theme of empowerment is woven throughout the narrative, providing a strong backbone to the romantic elements of the story.

Kaleb Charter, the broad-shouldered gardener, is more than just a romantic interest. He represents a break from the traditional male archetype often found in romance novels. His role as the gardener is symbolic of his down-to-earth nature and his ability to nurture and support the protagonist as she navigates her complex family dynamics. Kaleb’s character is well-developed, and his interactions with the protagonist are filled with genuine warmth and humor. His willingness to engage in a fake marriage to help the protagonist achieve her goals is both endearing and indicative of his deep-seated kindness.

The chemistry between the protagonist and Kaleb is palpable from their first meeting. Evergreen skillfully builds their relationship, allowing it to develop naturally over the course of the novel. The "fake dating" trope is handled with finesse, providing ample opportunity for comedic situations and heartfelt moments. The author’s decision to focus on the emotional connection between the characters, rather than relying on explicit scenes, allows for a more nuanced exploration of their relationship. This choice makes the novel accessible to a wider audience, including those who prefer their romance with "plenty of sizzle, yet none of the spice."

One of the standout aspects of Marrying the Gardener is its setting. Sunset, West Virginia, is brought to life with vivid descriptions and a cast of quirky supporting characters. The small-town atmosphere adds an additional layer of charm to the story, and the community’s involvement in the protagonist’s journey provides both comedic relief and poignant moments. Evergreen’s ability to create a sense of place is reminiscent of authors like Debbie Macomber and Kristan Higgins, who also excel at crafting engaging small-town romances.

The novel’s exploration of themes such as gender roles, family expectations, and personal growth is handled with a deft touch. Evergreen does not shy away from addressing the challenges faced by women in patriarchal societies, but she does so in a way that is both accessible and engaging. The protagonist’s struggle to assert her independence and claim her inheritance is a powerful narrative arc that will resonate with many readers. This theme of empowerment is further enhanced by the protagonist’s relationship with Kaleb, who supports her in her quest for autonomy without overshadowing her journey.

In comparison to other marriage of convenience stories, Marrying the Gardener stands out for its focus on character development and social commentary. While novels like Jasmine Guillory’s The Wedding Date and Tessa Dare’s When a Scot Ties the Knot offer delightful takes on the trope, Evergreen’s novel distinguishes itself by delving deeper into the societal issues that underpin the protagonist’s predicament. This added layer of depth makes the novel not only entertaining but also thought-provoking.

Overall, Marrying the Gardener is a charming and insightful addition to the romantic comedy genre. Camilla Evergreen has crafted a story that is both heartwarming and meaningful, with characters that linger in the reader’s mind long after the final page is turned. The novel’s blend of humor, romance, and social commentary ensures that it will appeal to a broad audience, from fans of lighthearted romcoms to those seeking a more substantial narrative. For readers looking for a romance that offers both laughs and food for thought, Marrying the Gardener is a must-read.