Isla Olsen's List Me With Your Best Shot is a delightful and engaging romantic comedy that explores themes of unrequited love, personal growth, and the unexpected twists life can take when you least expect them. This novel is a refreshing addition to the LGBTQ+ romance genre, offering readers a blend of humor, heart, and a touch of kink that keeps the pages turning.

The story centers around Jack, a character who is immediately relatable to anyone who has ever harbored a secret crush. Jack's predicament is both humorous and heartbreaking: he's been in love with his best friend, Trent, for two decades, and now he must watch him marry someone else. Olsen captures the essence of this emotional turmoil with a deft touch, balancing Jack's vulnerability with his determination to move on. The opening scene, where Jack finds himself in a tequila-fueled confession to his arch-nemesis, Alastor King, sets the stage for a journey that is as much about self-discovery as it is about romance.

Alastor King, Jack's high school nemesis, is a fascinating character in his own right. Initially presented as the antagonist, Alastor quickly becomes a complex figure whose motivations are not as straightforward as they seem. His proposal of a "month-long sex rehab" is both audacious and intriguing, serving as the catalyst for Jack's transformation. Alastor's character development is one of the highlights of the novel, as Olsen peels back layers to reveal a man who is more than just a foil to Jack's plans. The dynamic between Jack and Alastor is electric, filled with witty banter and genuine moments of connection that challenge their preconceived notions of each other.

The concept of a "kink list" as a means of personal growth is both innovative and entertaining. Olsen handles this aspect of the story with a light touch, ensuring that it never veers into gratuitous territory. Instead, the list serves as a metaphor for stepping out of one's comfort zone and embracing new experiences. Each item on the list is carefully chosen to push Jack's boundaries, and his reactions range from humorous to heartfelt. This journey of self-exploration is not just about sexual liberation; it's about Jack learning to let go of the past and open himself up to new possibilities.

One of the strengths of List Me With Your Best Shot is its ability to balance humor with genuine emotion. Olsen's writing is sharp and witty, with dialogue that sparkles and situations that elicit laughter. Yet, beneath the humor lies a poignant exploration of love and friendship. Jack's interactions with Trent, Alastor, and other supporting characters are imbued with authenticity, capturing the complexities of human relationships. The novel does not shy away from the messiness of emotions, and this honesty is what makes the story resonate with readers.

In terms of themes, the novel delves into the idea of letting go of unrequited love and the importance of self-acceptance. Jack's journey is one of empowerment, as he learns to define himself outside of his long-standing infatuation with Trent. The story also touches on the theme of unexpected connections, as Jack and Alastor's relationship evolves from animosity to something deeper. This transformation is handled with care, ensuring that it feels organic and believable.

Comparatively, Olsen's work can be likened to other contemporary LGBTQ+ romances that blend humor with heartfelt storytelling. Fans of Alexis Hall's Boyfriend Material or Casey McQuiston's Red, White & Royal Blue will find much to enjoy in Olsen's novel. Like these authors, Olsen has a knack for creating characters who are flawed yet lovable, and whose journeys are both entertaining and emotionally satisfying.

Overall, List Me With Your Best Shot is a charming and insightful read that will appeal to fans of romantic comedies and LGBTQ+ fiction alike. Isla Olsen has crafted a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, with characters who linger in the mind long after the final page is turned. Whether you're drawn in by the promise of humor, the allure of romance, or the exploration of personal growth, this novel delivers on all fronts. It's a testament to the power of stepping out of one's comfort zone and embracing the unexpected paths life can take.