It's Always Us by Stacy Williams takes the readers on a whirlwind journey of friendship, love, and self-discovery, set against a backdrop of beautifully painted small town dynamics and familial intricacies. Williams crafts a compelling narrative that explores the lengths to which we go to protect the ones we love, and the often complex web of relationships that shape who we are.

At the heart of the novel are the main characters, Sarah and Jack, whose lifelong friendship teeters on the brink of evolving into something much deeper. Williams perfectly captures the unspoken yearnings and the fear of risking a deep-rooted friendship for an uncertain romance, which many readers can resonate with. Their relationship is depicted with a tangible sense of realism and emotional depth, as they navigate not only their own feelings but also the projections and expectations of their tight-knit community.

The novel opens with Sarah returning to her quaint hometown after a successful stint in the city. Her return is motived by both professional setbacks and a personal loss that Williams describes with a tender poignancy. Jack, on the other hand, is a pillar of the community, having taken over his family's business. His life is seemingly rooted, but beneath the surface, Jack battles his own demons and unfulfilled aspirations. Their reunion sets off a series of events that unearth old secrets and test their bond in ways they never anticipated.

Williams excels in her rich, detailed descriptions of the setting, almost transforming the small town into a character of its own. From the local diner with its array of colorful characters to the serene spots by the lake where the two friends often retreat, the sense of place is vivid and compelling. This detailed setting serves as the perfect canvas for the themes of the novel – the idea that wherever life might take us, it's the bonds of home and heart that hold us together.

The supporting cast of characters is equally well-drawn, adding layers to the story. There is Rachel, Sarah's older sister, whose apparent perfectionism hides insecurities that are slowly unraveled through the narrative. Then there is Tom, Jack's brother, who adds an element of unpredictability with his wild ways and disdain for small-town life. Each character is meticulously crafted, with distinct voices and arcs that interlace smoothly with the main storyline, enhancing the overall thematic depth of the book.

The pacing of the novel is another of its strengths. Williams manages the flow of the narrative masterfully, keeping readers engaged with a good mix of introspective moments and dramatic revelations. The emotional stakes are high, and as secrets start to spill, the tension builds up, making it a compelling read. Williams doesn't shy away from delving into the messier aspects of human emotions, which lends an authenticity to her storytelling.

Throughout the novel, themes of redemption, resilience, and the power of forgiveness are explored with sensitivity and insight. Williams doesn't provide easy resolutions or overly idealized scenarios, which is refreshing. The conflicts feel real, and the resolutions, when they come, are earned, making the moments of reconciliation and understanding all the more impactful.

Perhaps, one of the novel's few shortcomings could be that the sheer number of subplots and characters might overwhelm some readers, occasionally causing the main thread to meander more than necessary. However, these moments are few and far between, and Williams deftly manages to bring the narrative back to its core focus, reinforcing the impact of the main storyline.

In conclusion, It's Always Us by Stacy Williams is a beautifully crafted novel that strikes a fine balance between being profoundly touching and entertaining. It's a story that embraces the complexities of human relationships — questioning how well we truly know those closest to us and what we owe them in terms of loyalty and love. Williams’ prose is evocative and assured, and she handles the intricate plot lines with a skilled hand. This book is recommended for those who enjoy heartfelt dramas punctuated by moments of genuine connection and understanding. It’s a reassuring reminder that in the end, no matter how far we roam, it’s always us who hold the keys to our happiness and healing.