It Never Was by Ivy Darling is a captivating exploration of human emotion, intricately woven into a narrative that challenges the typical boundaries of speculative fiction. At the core of the novel is a profound meditation on memory, loss, and the ephemeral nature of human relationships. Darling's elegant prose and her ability to delve deep into the psyches of her characters set this book apart as a significant contribution to contemporary literature.

The narrative centers around Elise, a young woman grappling with the sudden disappearance of her friend, Julian. As she navigates through the layers of her past and the overwhelming silence of Julian's absence, Elise begins to question the reality of her memories and the truths she has held dear. The storyline flits between the present and past, with memories acting almost as characters in their own right, pulling the reader into a reflective journey of what it means to remember and be forgotten.

Darling's prose is nothing short of poetic. The fluidity and precision in her descriptions capture the essence of each moment, whether it’s the painful sting of nostalgia or the quiet peace of acceptance. There is a musical quality to her writing that makes even the most ordinary scenes come alive with an undercurrent of something deeper, something more profound. This stylistic choice enhances the themes of the novel and allows the reader to feel each emotion alongside the characters.

The thematic depth of It Never Was is perhaps its most striking aspect. Ivy Darling uses the concept of disappearing as a multifaceted symbol - physical disappearance, the fading of memories, and the dissolution of self. Each interpretation is meticulously developed, creating a rich tapestry of ideas that invites readers to ponder long after they turn the last page. The book also subtly touches upon the impact of technology on human connections, weaving this contemporary dilemma into the traditional narrative framework without it feeling forced or out of place.

Character development is another forte of Darling’s writing. Elise is portrayed with such raw authenticity that her pain and confusion become palpable. Through her internal monologues and interactions with other characters, we see various dimensions of her personality unravel, making her a relatable and deeply human protagonist. The secondary characters, too, are crafted with care, each adding a layer of complexity to the narrative. Julian, though absent for most of the novel, feels omnipresent due to the detailed memories and the palpable void he leaves behind.

The pacing of the book is deliberate, echoing the process of recollection and the inevitable march of time. While some readers might find the pace slow, it is essential for the type of introspective narrative that Darling has chosen to pursue. The climax, when it arrives, does so quietly, yet it resonates deeply, emphasizing the book’s message about the impermanence and fluidity of life and memories.

On a critical note, while the intricate details are generally a boon to the narrative, there are segments where the description might feel overly indulgent, slowing down the pace more than necessary. However, these moments are few and far between and don’t significantly detract from the overall reading experience. Moreover, the philosophical and speculative elements of the story are likely to appeal to a niche audience, making it a gem for some and perhaps a ponderous read for others.

In summary, It Never Was by Ivy Darling is a beautifully crafted novel that strikes a fine balance between emotional depth and intellectual rigor. It’s a story that not only entertains but also challenges its readers to reflect on their own lives and the memories they hold dear. Its exploration of loss and remembrance is both timely and timeless, making it a worthy addition to the shelves of those who cherish profound, thought-provoking literature. Ivy Darling has proven herself to be a masterful storyteller, capable of turning an introspective narrative into a universal commentary on life’s fleeting nature.

Whether you're drawn to the elegance of fine prose, the complexity of human psychology, or the philosophical undertones of speculative fiction, It Never Was offers something of value. It’s a poignant reminder of the things we lose on our journey through life and a beautiful testament to the things that, despite never quite being tangible, leave a lasting impact on our hearts and minds.