Alyxandra Harvey's How to Marry a Duke, the second installment in the Cinderella Society series, is a delightful romp through the intricacies of Regency-era romance, infused with humor, wit, and a touch of adventure. The novel centers around Meg Swift, a spirited young woman who finds herself navigating the treacherous waters of high society while grappling with her own moral dilemmas. Harvey crafts a narrative that is not only engaging but also rich in themes of resilience, identity, and the complexities of love.

From the outset, Meg is portrayed as a resourceful and determined character. Faced with the financial burdens imposed by her uncle, who has tripled the estate rents, she resorts to stealing as a means of survival. This unconventional choice sets the stage for her character development throughout the story. Meg is not merely a thief; she is a survivor, embodying the struggles of many women of her time who had limited options. Her ability to mend roofs and plant turnips showcases her practicality and skill, making her a relatable and admirable protagonist.

In contrast, Dougal Black, the last of the Thorncroft duchy bloodline, is thrust into a world he knows little about after being plucked from a millhouse. His character represents the clash between social classes and the expectations placed upon individuals based on their lineage. Dougal's predicament—having to marry by the end of the year or risk having the Prince of Wales choose his bride—adds a layer of urgency to the narrative. He is portrayed as somewhat naive, which makes him endearing and allows for significant character growth as he learns the ropes of high society with Meg's guidance.

The relationship between Meg and Dougal is central to the story, and Harvey expertly develops their dynamic. Initially, Meg is reluctant to engage with Dougal, viewing him as just another debutante's prize. However, as they work together to navigate the challenges posed by the Cinderella Ball and the treasure hunters targeting Thorncroft Abbey, their relationship evolves from one of necessity to genuine affection. This transformation is beautifully illustrated through their shared experiences, highlighting the theme of partnership and mutual respect.

One of the most compelling aspects of How to Marry a Duke is its exploration of societal expectations and the roles women were forced to play during the Regency period. Meg's journey is not just about finding love; it is also about asserting her independence and challenging the status quo. Her refusal to abide by the traditional norms of courtship and marriage makes her a refreshing character in a genre often filled with passive heroines. Harvey's portrayal of Meg as a strong-willed woman who is unafraid to take charge of her destiny resonates with contemporary readers, making the story feel relevant even today.

The novel also delves into the theme of identity, particularly through Dougal's character. As he grapples with his newfound status and the expectations that come with it, readers witness his struggle to reconcile his past with his present. Dougal's journey of self-discovery is compelling, as he learns to embrace his heritage while remaining true to himself. This theme is further emphasized by the various debutantes vying for his attention, each representing different facets of societal expectations and the superficiality that often accompanies high society.

Harvey's writing is characterized by its vivid descriptions and engaging dialogue, which bring the world of Thorncroft Abbey to life. The setting is richly detailed, immersing readers in the opulence and intrigue of Regency England. The author skillfully balances humor with more serious themes, ensuring that the narrative remains light-hearted while still addressing important issues. The interactions between characters are often laced with wit, making for a delightful reading experience.

In comparison to other works within the genre, such as Julia Quinn's Bridgerton series or Tessa Dare's novels, How to Marry a Duke stands out for its unique blend of adventure and romance. While both authors also explore themes of societal expectations and personal growth, Harvey's focus on a heroine who actively challenges her circumstances adds a distinct flavor to the narrative. The inclusion of treasure hunters and the subplot surrounding Thorncroft Abbey's history further enrich the story, providing a sense of urgency and excitement that keeps readers engaged.

Overall, How to Marry a Duke is a captivating addition to the Cinderella Society series that combines romance, humor, and adventure in a way that is both entertaining and thought-provoking. Meg and Dougal's journey is one of self-discovery, partnership, and the courage to defy societal norms. Harvey's ability to create relatable characters and weave a compelling narrative makes this novel a must-read for fans of historical romance. Whether you are drawn in by the promise of love or the thrill of adventure, this book offers a satisfying escape into a world where anything is possible, and love can conquer all.