In His First Cherry Pie: A Double Virgin Valentine, Hope Ford delivers a tantalizing blend of romance, second chances, and the exploration of desire through the lens of two characters who are both familiar and yet transformed by time. The story centers around JD Ryan, a once-overweight boy turned NFL star, and Willa Baker, a woman who once overlooked him but now finds herself drawn back into his orbit. This narrative is not just about physical attraction; it delves into themes of self-worth, trust, and the complexities of love.

The premise of the book is engaging from the outset. JD is a character who embodies the classic "beast to beauty" trope, having transformed from a chubby, insecure teenager into a confident, muscular athlete. This transformation is not merely physical; it represents a journey of self-acceptance and empowerment. Ford skillfully illustrates JD's internal struggles with trust, particularly regarding women who may be attracted to his newfound fame and fortune rather than his true self. This adds depth to his character, making him relatable to readers who have experienced similar insecurities.

Willa, on the other hand, is a character who grapples with her own professional ambitions and personal feelings. As a journalist, she is tasked with writing a story about JD, which creates an interesting dynamic between the two. The initial agreement between them is purely transactional, but as they navigate their past and present, it becomes clear that their connection runs deeper than either anticipated. Ford does an excellent job of portraying Willa's internal conflict; she is torn between her professional obligations and her growing feelings for JD, which adds a layer of tension to the narrative.

One of the standout themes in the book is the idea of second chances. Both JD and Willa have histories that shape their current selves, and their reunion serves as a catalyst for personal growth. The author explores how past experiences can influence present relationships, and how love can blossom in unexpected ways. This theme resonates with readers who believe in the power of redemption and the possibility of rekindling old flames.

The chemistry between JD and Willa is palpable, and Ford does not shy away from depicting their physical attraction. The book is peppered with steamy scenes that are both explicit and tastefully written. JD's desire to lose his virginity to Willa adds a layer of urgency to their interactions, and Ford balances the sensuality with emotional depth. The exploration of JD's fantasies is particularly intriguing, as it allows readers to see a more vulnerable side of him, contrasting with his tough exterior as a football player.

Character development is another strong point in this novel. JD's journey from insecurity to confidence is well-crafted, and readers can witness his transformation as he learns to trust Willa and himself. Willa, too, evolves throughout the story; she moves from being a career-focused journalist to someone who recognizes the importance of love and connection. Their relationship is not without its challenges, and Ford does an admirable job of portraying the complexities of modern romance, including the impact of social media and public scrutiny on personal relationships.

The pacing of the story is well-executed, with a balance of romantic tension and character development. Ford keeps readers engaged with a mix of playful banter, heartfelt moments, and steamy encounters. The dialogue feels authentic, capturing the nuances of their relationship as it evolves from a professional arrangement to something much more profound.

In comparison to other contemporary romance novels, His First Cherry Pie stands out due to its unique premise and relatable characters. While many romance novels focus on the initial stages of attraction, Ford dives deeper into the emotional ramifications of past relationships and the importance of trust. Readers who enjoy stories with a strong emotional core, coupled with steamy romance, will find this book particularly appealing.

Overall, His First Cherry Pie: A Double Virgin Valentine is a delightful read that combines humor, heart, and heat. Hope Ford has crafted a story that not only entertains but also resonates on a deeper level. The themes of self-discovery, trust, and the power of love make this book a worthwhile addition to any romance reader's collection. Whether you're a fan of sports romance or simply enjoy a well-told love story, JD and Willa's journey is sure to captivate your heart.