Elsie Hawthorne's Her Shadow so Dark and Lovely is a mesmerizing foray into a world where the boundaries between reality and magic blur, and where the Library is not just a repository of books but a living entity with its own agenda. This novel is a compelling blend of fantasy, mystery, and romance, offering readers a richly woven narrative that explores themes of identity, destiny, and the power of choice.

At the heart of the story is our protagonist, a scribe who has long sought refuge in the anonymity of the Library. Her lack of magical prowess has been a source of familial disappointment, yet within the Library's walls, she finds solace and a sense of belonging. This setting is not merely a backdrop but a character in its own right, with its labyrinthine corridors and enigmatic aura. The Library's mysterious nature is reminiscent of the magical institutions found in works like Susanna Clarke's Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell, where the setting itself plays a pivotal role in shaping the narrative.

The inciting incident—a seemingly innocuous book left on her desk—propels the protagonist into a whirlwind of events that strip her of her voice and memory, marking her with a dark curse. This transformation is not just physical but symbolic, representing the loss of identity and the struggle to reclaim it. Hawthorne deftly uses this motif to explore the theme of self-discovery, as the protagonist must navigate a world that suddenly seems alien and hostile.

Enter Sila, the enigmatic Librarian whose presence is both a source of intrigue and tension. Sila is a complex character, embodying the duality of protector and potential adversary. Her relationship with the protagonist is fraught with tension, yet it is this very tension that adds depth to their interactions. Sila's character is reminiscent of the morally ambiguous figures found in Leigh Bardugo's Grishaverse, where characters often straddle the line between light and dark, forcing readers to question their motivations and loyalties.

The dynamic between the protagonist and Sila is central to the narrative, offering a nuanced exploration of trust and vulnerability. As the protagonist grapples with her newfound reality, Sila becomes both a guide and a catalyst for change. Their evolving relationship is a testament to Hawthorne's skill in crafting characters that are both relatable and compelling. The chemistry between them is palpable, adding a layer of romantic tension that is both subtle and profound.

Hawthorne's prose is both lyrical and evocative, painting vivid images of the Library's shadowy depths and the protagonist's internal turmoil. Her ability to weave intricate details into the narrative enhances the world-building, immersing readers in a universe that feels both fantastical and tangible. The pacing is well-balanced, with moments of introspection interspersed with action-packed sequences that keep readers engaged.

Thematically, Her Shadow so Dark and Lovely delves into the concept of destiny versus free will. The protagonist's journey is one of empowerment, as she learns to navigate the expectations of the high court and the Library's own machinations. This theme is echoed in the works of authors like Naomi Novik, whose novels often explore the tension between societal expectations and personal agency.

Moreover, the novel's exploration of identity and belonging resonates with readers on a personal level. The protagonist's struggle to reconcile her past with her present is a universal theme, one that speaks to anyone who has ever felt out of place or underestimated. Hawthorne's portrayal of this journey is both poignant and inspiring, offering a message of hope and resilience.

In conclusion, Her Shadow so Dark and Lovely is a captivating tale that will appeal to fans of fantasy and romance alike. Elsie Hawthorne has crafted a story that is both enchanting and thought-provoking, with characters that linger in the mind long after the final page is turned. The novel's exploration of identity, destiny, and the power of choice is both timely and timeless, making it a must-read for anyone seeking a story that is as dark as it is lovely.

For readers who enjoy the intricate world-building of authors like V.E. Schwab or the character-driven narratives of Sarah J. Maas, Hawthorne's novel offers a fresh and engaging perspective. Her Shadow so Dark and Lovely is a testament to the enduring power of storytelling, a reminder that even in the darkest of shadows, there is light to be found.