Her Knotty List by Ari Wright is a contemporary romance novel that delves into the complexities of finding love when least expected, coupled with the challenges of confronting one's past. At its heart, the book is a journey of self-discovery and emotional growth, woven through with threads of humor and heartache.

The story follows Eliza Jane, a young, spirited professional who is determined to tackle her newly crafted "knotty" list—a collection of personal and professional goals she set for herself after a particularly tumultuous breakup and a career setback. Unlike the typical bucket list, Eliza's involves intricate challenges that push her boundaries, both emotionally and mentally. These challenges range from learning to knit, which lends the book its title, to confronting her fears of commitment and vulnerability.

Wright’s protagonist, Eliza, is a well-rounded character whose witty internal monologue provides much of the book's charm. Her journey is one laced with human frailties and strengths, making her extremely relatable. Wright skillfully paints Eliza’s world with a blend of sharp humor and poignant moments, her writing style brisk and engaging, keeping the reader thoroughly entertained throughout. Despite the premise of personal growth, the novel does not become preachy or tedious; instead, it maintains a light, breezy tone that is perfect for a weekend read.

The foil to Eliza's character comes in the form of Jamie Donovan, her enigmatic neighbor who inadvertently becomes part of her knotty list adventures. Jamie is a character crafted with layers that are revealed gradually, teasing the reader’s curiosity and emotions as his backstory unfolds. His chemistry with Eliza is palpable, marked by snappy dialogue and a slow-burning romance that serves as the backbone of the plot. Wright does a commendable job of developing their relationship organically, allowing for authentic interactions that build from awkward first encounters to deeper, meaningful connections.

One of the most striking aspects of Her Knotty List is the attention given to secondary characters. Each supporting character is vividly drawn and adds depth to the narrative. From Eliza's supportive yet quirky group of friends to her mentor-like figure Mrs. Patterson, who provides wisdom at pivotal moments, these characters enrich the story, making Eliza’s world feel fully realized and vibrant.

Thematically, the novel tackles several relevant topics such as the impact of social media on relationships, the pursuit of career fulfillment versus personal happiness, and the importance of mental health. Wright manages to address these issues subtly through the actions and decisions of her characters without veering away from the novel’s primary focus on romance and personal growth. Additionally, the setting—a bustling urban landscape dotted with cozy, intimate spaces—acts as an ideal backdrop for the unfolding drama, complementing the story’s mood and pace perfectly.

However, the book is not without its minor pitfalls. At certain junctures, the pacing seems to stutter, particularly when delving into Eliza’s professional life, which, although integral to her character development, can occasionally detract from the primary narrative arc. Moreover, some readers might find Eliza's list slightly gimmicky as a plot device, though this does little to diminish the overall enjoyment of the story.

In conclusion, Her Knotty List by Ari Wright is a charming, insightful novel that combines romance with a slice of life appeal. It deftly captures the essence of contemporary relationships through its flawed yet endearing characters. The narrative is engaging, funny, and at times, moving, making it a commendable addition to the genre. Readers looking for a light, yet thoughtful read will find this book to be a delightful escape, proving once again that sometimes, the most significant journeys involve untangling the knots within ourselves.