Ava MacAdams' Her Duke Next Door is a captivating journey into the intricacies of love, loss, and societal expectations set against the backdrop of the Regency era. This novel offers a compelling blend of romance and drama, driven by well-crafted characters and a plot that keeps readers engaged from start to finish.

The story centers around two protagonists, Mary and Duke Dominique, each grappling with their own pasts and societal judgments. Mary, a widow, has chosen a life of solitude to protect her daughter from the prying eyes of the Ton after her husband's scandalous death. Her character is a testament to resilience and maternal devotion, embodying the struggles of a woman trying to shield her child from the harsh realities of society. MacAdams paints Mary as a strong, independent figure, yet one who is not immune to vulnerability. Her journey is one of self-discovery and healing, as she learns to open her heart once more.

On the other hand, Duke Dominique is shrouded in mystery and rumor. Accused of killing his own wife, he is a man burdened by guilt and societal condemnation. His avoidance of his estate and daughter adds layers to his character, making him a complex figure who is both feared and misunderstood. Dominique's character development is one of the highlights of the novel. As the story unfolds, readers are given glimpses into his true nature, revealing a man who is not the villain society has painted him to be, but rather a father yearning for redemption and connection.

The relationship between Mary and Dominique is the heart of the novel. Their initial encounter, sparked by a near accident, sets the stage for a dynamic interplay of emotions. MacAdams skillfully navigates their evolving relationship, marked by tension, misunderstandings, and gradual trust. The chemistry between the two is palpable, and their interactions are laced with wit and passion. The author does an excellent job of portraying their journey from adversaries to allies, and eventually, to lovers.

A significant theme in Her Duke Next Door is the impact of societal expectations and rumors. Both Mary and Dominique are victims of the Ton's harsh judgments, and their stories highlight the destructive power of gossip and prejudice. MacAdams uses their experiences to critique the rigid social structures of the Regency era, emphasizing the need for empathy and understanding. This theme resonates with contemporary readers, drawing parallels to modern-day issues of reputation and societal pressure.

The subplot involving their daughters adds a delightful layer to the narrative. The young girls, in their innocence and determination, serve as catalysts for their parents' relationship. Their schemes to bring Mary and Dominique together are both humorous and heartwarming, providing moments of levity amidst the more serious themes. This element of the story underscores the importance of family and the bonds that can form in the most unexpected ways.

MacAdams' writing style is both elegant and accessible, capturing the essence of the Regency era while making it relatable to modern readers. Her attention to detail in describing the settings and social customs immerses readers in the time period, enhancing the overall reading experience. The dialogue is sharp and engaging, reflecting the characters' personalities and the societal norms of the time.

In comparison to other Regency romances, Her Duke Next Door stands out for its depth of character and exploration of themes beyond the typical romantic tropes. While authors like Julia Quinn and Lisa Kleypas often focus on the lighter, more whimsical aspects of the era, MacAdams delves into the darker, more complex issues faced by her characters. This approach adds a layer of realism to the story, making it a more thought-provoking read.

Overall, Her Duke Next Door is a beautifully crafted novel that offers a fresh take on the Regency romance genre. Its exploration of themes such as redemption, societal judgment, and the power of love makes it a compelling read for fans of historical romance. Ava MacAdams has created a story that is both entertaining and meaningful, leaving readers with much to ponder long after the final page is turned.

For those seeking a romance that is both steamy and substantial, Her Duke Next Door is a must-read. It is a testament to the enduring power of love and the courage it takes to defy societal expectations in pursuit of happiness.