Meg Everly’s Hard to Judge is a bold exploration of love, identity, and the complexities of human relationships. The novel challenges conventional narratives by presenting a love story that defies traditional boundaries, focusing on the intricate dynamics between Hailey Fitzpatrick, Hotaru Kido, and Arlo Judge. This book is not just a romance; it’s a deep dive into the emotional landscapes of its characters, offering readers a fresh perspective on what it means to find happiness and fulfillment in unexpected places.

At the heart of Hard to Judge is Hailey Fitzpatrick, a relationship expert who finds herself in an unconventional situation. Her boyfriend, Arlo, is in love with another man, Hotaru. Rather than succumbing to jealousy or heartbreak, Hailey sees this as an opportunity for all three of them to achieve their happily ever after (HEA). This premise sets the stage for a narrative that is both daring and thought-provoking, inviting readers to question societal norms and the nature of love itself.

Hailey’s character is a refreshing departure from the typical romantic heroine. Her confidence in her own identity and her willingness to embrace an unconventional relationship dynamic make her a compelling protagonist. She is not portrayed as a martyr or a victim; instead, she is a catalyst for change, pushing Arlo and Hotaru to confront their feelings and embrace their true selves. Her journey is one of self-discovery and empowerment, and Everly does an excellent job of portraying her as a multi-dimensional character with depth and complexity.

Hotaru Kido, on the other hand, is a character torn between desire and fear. His love for Arlo is palpable, yet he is hesitant to act on it due to the potential consequences. Everly skillfully captures Hotaru’s internal struggle, making him a relatable and sympathetic character. His interactions with Hailey are particularly intriguing, as they defy the expected animosity between romantic rivals. Instead, their relationship evolves into a unique bond, characterized by mutual respect and understanding.

Arlo Judge is perhaps the most complex character in the novel. His past is marred by trauma, having killed his abuser in self-defense. This backstory adds a layer of depth to his character, as he grapples with guilt and the fear of losing the people he loves. Arlo’s journey is one of redemption and healing, and his relationship with Hailey and Hotaru becomes a source of strength and solace. Everly’s portrayal of Arlo’s emotional growth is both poignant and realistic, making his character arc one of the most compelling aspects of the novel.

The themes of Hard to Judge are both timely and timeless. The novel explores the fluidity of love and the importance of authenticity in relationships. It challenges the notion of a singular, monogamous love story, presenting instead a narrative where love is multifaceted and inclusive. Everly’s writing encourages readers to embrace diversity in love and to question the societal constructs that dictate what relationships should look like.

In terms of style, Everly’s prose is both engaging and evocative. Her ability to convey the emotional depth of her characters is impressive, and her dialogue is both natural and impactful. The pacing of the novel is well-balanced, allowing for moments of introspection and tension without losing momentum. The narrative is structured in a way that keeps readers invested in the characters’ journeys, culminating in a satisfying and thought-provoking conclusion.

Comparatively, Hard to Judge shares thematic similarities with works like Red, White & Royal Blue by Casey McQuiston and The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo by Taylor Jenkins Reid. Like these novels, Everly’s book challenges traditional narratives and celebrates the diversity of love. However, Hard to Judge stands out for its focus on a polyamorous relationship, a topic that is less frequently explored in mainstream romance literature.

Overall, Hard to Judge is a compelling and thought-provoking read that will resonate with readers who appreciate stories that challenge the status quo. Meg Everly has crafted a narrative that is both entertaining and enlightening, offering a fresh perspective on love and relationships. The novel’s exploration of identity, acceptance, and the courage to embrace one’s true self makes it a standout in the romance genre.

For readers seeking a romance novel that goes beyond the conventional, Hard to Judge is a must-read. Its rich character development, engaging narrative, and bold themes make it a memorable addition to any bookshelf. Whether you’re a fan of romance or simply looking for a story that challenges societal norms, this book is sure to leave a lasting impression.