Charlie Donlea’s Guess Again is a gripping thriller that delves into the haunting disappearance of a young girl and the relentless pursuit of truth by a former detective turned ER doctor. Set against the backdrop of a small Wisconsin lake community, the novel weaves a complex narrative filled with suspense, psychological intrigue, and unexpected revelations.

The story begins with the mysterious vanishing of Callie Jones, a 17-year-old high school volleyball star, whose disappearance has left a lingering shadow over the town of Cherryview. The case, once a media sensation, has grown cold over the years, but the pain and unanswered questions remain fresh for Callie’s family and the community. Donlea skillfully captures the emotional toll of such a tragedy, illustrating how the absence of closure can haunt those left behind.

Enter Ethan Hall, a former detective who has traded the grim realities of the kid crime division for the life-saving chaos of an ER doctor. Ethan is a compelling protagonist, marked by his internal conflict and a desire to escape the darkness of his past. His character is richly developed, with Donlea providing glimpses into Ethan’s psyche, revealing a man torn between his duty to the truth and his need for personal peace. This duality makes Ethan a relatable and engaging character, as readers are drawn into his struggle to reconcile his past with his present.

The catalyst for Ethan’s return to detective work is a plea from his former partner, Pete Kramer, who is now facing his own mortality. Pete’s request is more than just a professional obligation; it is a personal mission to bring closure to the Jones family and to ease his own conscience. This dynamic between Ethan and Pete adds depth to the narrative, highlighting themes of loyalty, redemption, and the enduring impact of unresolved cases on those who investigate them.

As Ethan delves back into the investigation, Donlea masterfully builds tension, using the oppressive heatwave as a metaphor for the mounting pressure Ethan faces. The author’s attention to detail is evident in the vivid descriptions of the small-town setting, which becomes a character in its own right, with its secrets and whispers echoing through the pages.

One of the most intriguing aspects of Guess Again is Ethan’s unconventional approach to solving the case. His decision to seek insight from an inmate in a maximum-security prison introduces a fascinating psychological element to the story. This interaction serves as a catalyst for Ethan’s deeper understanding of the case, as well as his own personal demons. Donlea’s exploration of the mind games and manipulation involved in this relationship adds layers to the narrative, keeping readers on the edge of their seats.

The novel’s plot is intricately woven, with Donlea expertly balancing multiple threads that converge in a shocking and satisfying conclusion. The twists and turns are well-executed, with each revelation adding to the complexity of the mystery. The pacing is relentless, yet Donlea allows moments of introspection that provide insight into the characters’ motivations and fears.

In terms of themes, Guess Again explores the nature of truth and the lengths to which individuals will go to uncover it. The novel also examines the impact of unresolved trauma and the ways in which people cope with loss and guilt. Donlea’s portrayal of these themes is both poignant and thought-provoking, inviting readers to reflect on their own perceptions of justice and closure.

Comparatively, Donlea’s work can be likened to the psychological depth found in Gillian Flynn’s Gone Girl or the intricate plotting of Tana French’s Dublin Murder Squad series. Like these authors, Donlea excels at creating a sense of unease and suspense, drawing readers into a world where nothing is as it seems.

Overall, Guess Again is a compelling and expertly crafted thriller that will appeal to fans of psychological mysteries and crime fiction. Charlie Donlea’s ability to blend character-driven storytelling with a tightly woven plot makes this novel a standout in the genre. With its rich character development, atmospheric setting, and thought-provoking themes, Guess Again is a must-read for anyone seeking a thrilling and emotionally resonant reading experience.