Abigail Hunter's First Puck is a compelling addition to the MM college romance genre, weaving together themes of friendship, love, and the pursuit of dreams. Set against the backdrop of college ice hockey, the novel explores the intricate dynamics between Alex and Brad, two best friends on the cusp of major life changes. With its blend of sports drama and emotional depth, First Puck offers readers a heartfelt journey that resonates with anyone who has ever faced the challenge of balancing personal aspirations with deep-seated relationships.

The story is primarily driven by its two protagonists, Alex and Brad, whose intertwined lives form the core of the narrative. Alex is portrayed as a determined and ambitious young man, ready to embark on a professional hockey career in the NHL. His internal conflict is palpable as he grapples with his unrequited love for Brad and the impending separation that his NHL draft represents. Hunter skillfully captures Alex's vulnerability and determination, making him a relatable and sympathetic character.

Brad, on the other hand, is a complex character whose journey is marked by uncertainty and introspection. His initial obliviousness to Alex's feelings adds a layer of tension to the story, but as the narrative unfolds, Brad's possessive nature and deep-seated affection for Alex come to the forefront. This transformation is handled with nuance, allowing readers to witness Brad's growth and the eventual realization of his own feelings. The evolution of Brad's character is one of the novel's highlights, showcasing Hunter's ability to craft multidimensional characters.

The theme of first experiences is a recurring motif throughout the novel, symbolizing both the innocence and intensity of Alex and Brad's relationship. From their first steps to their first kiss, these shared milestones underscore the depth of their bond. The notion of being each other's "first" is not only a testament to their history but also a poignant reminder of the impending changes that threaten to alter their dynamic. This theme is further reinforced by the title, First Puck, which cleverly encapsulates the idea of new beginnings and the pivotal moments that define their relationship.

Hunter's use of the fake dating trope adds an intriguing layer to the narrative, serving as a catalyst for the characters' emotional revelations. The introduction of the freshman team captain as a romantic foil creates a sense of urgency and forces both Alex and Brad to confront their true feelings. This plot device, while familiar, is executed with finesse, allowing for moments of humor, tension, and ultimately, resolution. The fake dating scenario also provides a platform for exploring themes of jealousy and possessiveness, which are deftly woven into the storyline.

The novel's setting within the world of college ice hockey adds an authentic and dynamic backdrop to the story. Hunter's attention to detail in depicting the sport and its demands lends credibility to the narrative, immersing readers in the competitive and high-stakes environment of collegiate athletics. The ice hockey scenes are vividly described, capturing the intensity and camaraderie that define the sport. This setting not only enhances the plot but also serves as a metaphor for the characters' personal struggles and triumphs.

In terms of style, Hunter's writing is both engaging and evocative, with a keen sense of pacing that keeps the narrative moving forward. The dialogue is sharp and realistic, capturing the nuances of the characters' interactions and adding depth to their relationships. The explicit scenes, while steamy, are handled with care and contribute to the overall emotional arc of the story. It's worth noting that these scenes are recommended for readers 18+, aligning with the novel's mature themes.

Comparatively, First Puck shares thematic similarities with other works in the MM romance genre, such as Sarina Bowen's Him series, which also explores the intersection of sports and romance. However, Hunter's novel distinguishes itself through its focus on the concept of "firsts" and the unique dynamic between Alex and Brad. The exploration of unrequited love and the transition from friendship to romance is handled with sensitivity and depth, making First Puck a standout in its genre.

Overall, First Puck is a captivating and emotionally resonant novel that will appeal to fans of MM romance and sports fiction alike. Abigail Hunter has crafted a story that is both heartwarming and thought-provoking, with characters that linger in the reader's mind long after the final page. Whether you're drawn to the thrill of ice hockey or the complexities of first love, First Puck offers a satisfying and memorable reading experience.