R.L. Merrill's Everything's Better With You is a delightful exploration of love, resilience, and the complexities of human relationships, wrapped up in a sports-themed romance that is both heartwarming and deeply engaging. Inspired by the feel-good charm of TED LASSO, this novel offers a refreshing take on the romance genre by focusing on two male protagonists whose lives have been intertwined by fate and longing for over a decade.

The story centers around Leslie Payton, a retired quarterback known as the “nicest guy in the NFL,” and Joe Judd, a former college cheerleader who has since become a reality TV sensation. Their connection began fifteen years ago with a night of deep conversation, setting the stage for years of pining and unfulfilled desires. This long-distance yearning is beautifully captured through their text and phone exchanges, which serve as a testament to their enduring bond despite the physical distance.

One of the novel's most compelling themes is the passage of time and its impact on the body and spirit. Both Leslie and Joe are acutely aware of the ticking clock on their physical abilities—Leslie due to his history of Traumatic Brain Injury and Joe from the wear and tear of a demanding performance career. This shared vulnerability adds a poignant layer to their relationship, as they grapple with the fear of losing not only their careers but also the chance to be together.

Character development is a standout feature in Merrill's narrative. Leslie is portrayed as a man of integrity and warmth, whose kindness is matched only by his determination to make the most of the time he has left. His desire to turn the “what if” into reality with Joe is both urgent and tender, making him a deeply sympathetic character. Joe, on the other hand, is a complex figure who struggles with self-worth and the pressure to perform. His journey towards self-acceptance and the realization that he deserves love and happiness is both moving and relatable.

The chemistry between Leslie and Joe is electric, and Merrill does an excellent job of balancing humor and heat in their interactions. The novel is filled with witty banter and playful rivalry, especially as they take on roles as football and cheer coaches at their alma mater. This setting not only provides a backdrop for their romance but also allows for a broader commentary on the challenges of toxic masculinity and the importance of open dialogue about sex and relationships.

In terms of narrative structure, the use of a wager to trigger their competitive sides is a clever device that propels the story forward. It adds an element of tension and excitement, as both characters are forced to confront their fears and secrets. The revelation of these secrets serves as a pivotal moment in the story, presenting an obstacle that tests the strength of their relationship.

Merrill's writing is both engaging and insightful, with a keen eye for detail and an ear for authentic dialogue. The inclusion of elements such as mesh crop tops, shirtless car wash scenes, and phone sex therapy adds a layer of fun and playfulness to the story, making it a thoroughly enjoyable read. These moments of levity are balanced by the deeper emotional currents that run through the narrative, creating a well-rounded and satisfying romance.

When compared to other romance novels featuring LGBTQ+ protagonists, Everything's Better With You stands out for its mature and nuanced portrayal of love and partnership. It shares thematic similarities with works by authors like Alexis Hall and Casey McQuiston, who also explore the complexities of queer relationships with humor and heart. However, Merrill's focus on the intersection of sports and romance, along with the exploration of aging and physical limitations, gives this novel a unique and refreshing perspective.

Overall, Everything's Better With You is a compelling and heartwarming read that will resonate with fans of romance and sports alike. It is a testament to the power of love to transcend time and distance, and a reminder that true partnership requires vulnerability, honesty, and a willingness to meet each other halfway. Recommended for readers who appreciate open and honest dialogue, challenges to traditional gender norms, and a healthy dose of humor and heart.