Avery Collins' Cruel When He Smiles is a gripping exploration of psychological manipulation, emotional entanglement, and the complex interplay of power dynamics in human relationships. The novel delves into the dark and often unsettling world of control and submission, where the lines between desire and destruction blur, leaving readers questioning the nature of love and obsession.

At the heart of the story are two compelling characters: Liam Callahan and Nate Carter. Liam is a master manipulator, trained to observe and control, a man who thrives on breaking things—and people. His character is meticulously crafted, embodying the archetype of the charming yet dangerous antagonist. Collins skillfully portrays Liam as a character who is both alluring and terrifying, a man whose calculated actions are driven by a need to possess and dominate. His journey is one of internal conflict, as he grapples with unexpected emotions that Nate stirs within him. The author’s ability to depict Liam’s transformation from a cold manipulator to someone who experiences genuine feelings of want, possession, and hunger is both fascinating and chilling.

Nate Carter, on the other hand, is the embodiment of resistance and vulnerability. He is introduced as a character who is aware of the danger Liam poses, yet finds himself irresistibly drawn to him. Nate’s struggle with his own identity and autonomy is a central theme of the novel. Collins captures Nate’s internal turmoil with precision, illustrating his battle between the desire to maintain control over his own life and the inexplicable pull towards Liam’s destructive influence. Nate’s character development is a testament to Collins’ skill in creating multi-dimensional characters who are both relatable and complex.

The novel’s structure is cleverly designed, with alternating perspectives that allow readers to delve into the minds of both Liam and Nate. This narrative technique not only enhances the depth of the characters but also provides a comprehensive view of their psychological states. The dual perspectives create a sense of intimacy, drawing readers into the intricate dance of manipulation and desire that defines their relationship.

Themes of control, power, and identity are intricately woven throughout the narrative. Collins explores the idea of control not just as a physical or external force, but as a deeply psychological and emotional construct. Liam’s need to control Nate is juxtaposed with Nate’s struggle to maintain his sense of self, creating a tension that is both palpable and thought-provoking. The novel raises important questions about the nature of power in relationships and the extent to which individuals are willing to go to assert or relinquish control.

Moreover, the theme of identity is central to the story. Nate’s journey is one of self-discovery, as he navigates the blurred lines between his own desires and the influence of Liam’s manipulation. Collins adeptly portrays the confusion and vulnerability that accompany such a journey, making Nate’s character arc both compelling and relatable. The novel challenges readers to consider the ways in which identity is shaped by external forces and the struggle to maintain autonomy in the face of overwhelming pressure.

In terms of style, Collins’ writing is both evocative and precise. The prose is imbued with a sense of tension and urgency, reflecting the intensity of the characters’ emotions and the high stakes of their interactions. The author’s use of language is deliberate, with each word carefully chosen to convey the complexity of the characters’ inner worlds. This attention to detail enhances the overall impact of the novel, immersing readers in a world that is as captivating as it is unsettling.

Comparatively, Cruel When He Smiles shares thematic similarities with works by authors such as E.L. James and Sylvia Day, who also explore the dynamics of power and control in relationships. However, Collins distinguishes herself through her nuanced portrayal of psychological manipulation and the depth of her character development. While James and Day often focus on the erotic aspects of such relationships, Collins delves deeper into the psychological and emotional ramifications, offering a more introspective and thought-provoking narrative.

Overall, Cruel When He Smiles is a compelling and unsettling exploration of the darker aspects of human relationships. Avery Collins has crafted a novel that is both a psychological thriller and a poignant examination of identity and autonomy. The characters of Liam and Nate are unforgettable, their journey a haunting reminder of the complexities of love, desire, and control. For readers who enjoy stories that challenge their perceptions and delve into the intricacies of the human psyche, this novel is a must-read.