May Archer's Cherry Picked is a delightful foray into the world of romantic comedy, where the lines between friendship and love blur in the most charming of ways. The novel centers around Hawk Sunday, a character whose endearing awkwardness and earnestness make him instantly relatable. His quest to lose his virginity, particularly to his brother's best friend, Jack Wyatt, sets the stage for a story filled with humor, heart, and a touch of the absurd.

One of the most compelling aspects of Cherry Picked is its exploration of unrequited love and the courage it takes to confront one's feelings. Hawk has been harboring a crush on Jack for seven years, a testament to his patience and the depth of his emotions. This long-standing infatuation is not just a plot device but a window into Hawk's character, showcasing his loyalty and romantic idealism. Archer does a commendable job of portraying Hawk as more than just a lovesick young man; he is a multifaceted character with dreams, insecurities, and a penchant for classic literature, particularly Pride and Prejudice.

Jack Wyatt, on the other hand, is the quintessential romantic hero with a twist. He is tall, handsome, and kind, yet his initial reluctance to see Hawk as anything other than a friend adds an intriguing layer to his character. Archer skillfully navigates Jack's internal conflict, making his journey from protective friend to romantic partner both believable and satisfying. The chemistry between Hawk and Jack is palpable, and their interactions are laced with witty banter and genuine affection, making their eventual union all the more rewarding.

Thematically, Cherry Picked delves into the idea of self-discovery and the courage to pursue one's desires. Hawk's determination to shed his "honorary little brother" status and be seen as a man in his own right is a powerful narrative arc. It speaks to the universal struggle of asserting one's identity and the fear of rejection that often accompanies it. Archer's portrayal of this journey is both humorous and heartfelt, striking a balance that keeps the reader engaged and invested in Hawk's outcome.

Moreover, the novel touches on the theme of protection versus possession. Jack's initial instinct to protect Hawk from potential heartbreak is juxtaposed with his growing realization that Hawk is not a boy in need of safeguarding but a man worthy of love and respect. This evolution in Jack's perception is a testament to Archer's ability to craft characters who grow and change in meaningful ways.

In terms of character development, Archer excels in creating a cast that is both diverse and dynamic. Hawk's transformation from a shy, bookish young man to someone who confidently pursues his desires is particularly well-executed. His love for romance novels and his tendency to view life through the lens of a romantic hero add depth to his character and provide a unique perspective on his interactions with Jack.

Jack's journey is equally compelling. His struggle to reconcile his protective instincts with his growing feelings for Hawk is portrayed with nuance and sensitivity. Archer avoids the trap of making Jack a one-dimensional character, instead presenting him as a man grappling with his own fears and insecurities. This complexity adds richness to the narrative and makes Jack's eventual acceptance of his feelings for Hawk all the more satisfying.

Comparatively, Cherry Picked shares thematic similarities with other contemporary romance novels, such as Alexis Hall's Boyfriend Material and Casey McQuiston's Red, White & Royal Blue. Like these works, Archer's novel combines humor, romance, and a touch of social commentary to create a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking. However, Archer's unique voice and her focus on the dynamics of friendship and love set Cherry Picked apart, offering readers a fresh take on familiar tropes.

Overall, Cherry Picked is a delightful read that will appeal to fans of romantic comedies and those who appreciate stories of personal growth and self-discovery. May Archer has crafted a novel that is both heartwarming and humorous, with characters who are as endearing as they are relatable. The book's exploration of love, friendship, and the courage to pursue one's desires makes it a standout in the genre, and a must-read for anyone looking for a story that is as sweet as it is satisfying.

In conclusion, Cherry Picked is a testament to May Archer's talent for storytelling and her ability to create characters who resonate with readers. It is a novel that celebrates the complexities of love and the joy of finding one's place in the world, all while delivering a healthy dose of laughter and romance. Whether you're a fan of the genre or new to Archer's work, this book is sure to leave a lasting impression.