Sara Ney's Can't Always Get What You Want is a delightful foray into the world of secret romances, familial loyalty, and the thrilling backdrop of professional hockey. This novel, with its engaging narrative and relatable characters, offers a fresh take on the classic romantic trope of forbidden love, making it a compelling read for fans of contemporary romance.

At the heart of the story is the protagonist, who finds herself caught between two of the most important aspects of her life: her family and her burgeoning romance. The Montagalo household's rules are simple yet sacred: family comes first, and dating her brother's teammates is strictly off-limits. However, as the blurb suggests, rules are meant to be broken, especially when love is involved.

The narrative kicks off with a seemingly innocuous exchange on a dating app between the protagonist and Luca Babineaux, a forward on the Houston Baddies. Ney skillfully captures the excitement and trepidation of online flirtation, which quickly escalates into a secret romance. Luca is portrayed as the quintessential romantic hero—charming, attractive, and with a hint of vulnerability that makes him irresistible. His character is well-developed, and readers will find themselves rooting for him as he navigates the complexities of a relationship that must remain hidden.

One of the novel's strengths is its exploration of the theme of loyalty versus self-fulfillment. The protagonist is torn between her loyalty to her brother, Gio, and her desire to pursue a relationship with Luca. This internal conflict is portrayed with nuance and depth, making her a relatable and sympathetic character. Ney does an excellent job of illustrating the anxiety and guilt that accompany her secret romance, adding layers to her character and making her journey all the more compelling.

The dynamic between the protagonist and her brother Gio is another highlight of the book. Their relationship is characterized by a mix of sibling rivalry and deep-seated affection, which adds a layer of complexity to the narrative. Gio's overprotectiveness is both endearing and frustrating, and Ney captures this duality with finesse. The tension between the siblings is palpable, and readers will find themselves invested in how their relationship evolves as the story progresses.

In terms of pacing, Ney strikes a balance between the thrill of the secret romance and the emotional weight of the protagonist's dilemma. The narrative moves swiftly, with enough twists and turns to keep readers engaged. The chemistry between the protagonist and Luca is electric, and their interactions are filled with witty banter and genuine emotion. Ney's writing is crisp and engaging, making it easy for readers to become immersed in the story.

Comparatively, Can't Always Get What You Want shares thematic similarities with other contemporary romance novels that explore forbidden love and familial expectations. For instance, it echoes elements from Elle Kennedy's Off-Campus series, where the world of college hockey serves as a backdrop for romantic entanglements. However, Ney's novel stands out due to its focus on the protagonist's internal struggle and the emphasis on sibling relationships, offering a fresh perspective within the genre.

The novel also delves into the world of professional hockey, providing a vibrant and exciting setting for the romance to unfold. Ney's portrayal of the sport is both authentic and exhilarating, adding an extra layer of excitement to the narrative. The hockey scenes are well-researched and vividly described, making them a treat for fans of the sport and newcomers alike.

Overall, Can't Always Get What You Want is a captivating read that combines romance, humor, and emotional depth. Sara Ney has crafted a story that resonates with readers, offering a perfect blend of heartwarming moments and thought-provoking dilemmas. The novel's exploration of themes such as loyalty, self-discovery, and the complexities of love make it a standout in the contemporary romance genre.

For those seeking a romance that is both entertaining and emotionally resonant, Can't Always Get What You Want is a must-read. Its engaging characters, dynamic relationships, and thrilling setting make it a book that will linger in readers' minds long after the final page is turned.