Jody Hedlund’s Calling on the Matchmaker is a compelling historical romance that deftly intertwines themes of love, sacrifice, and societal expectations. Set against the backdrop of 19th-century St. Louis, the novel explores the lives of two protagonists, Finola Shanahan and Riley Rafferty, who are brought together by circumstances that challenge their preconceived notions about life and love.

At the heart of the story is Finola Shanahan, a character haunted by the tragic death of her sister. This trauma has left her with a profound sense of unworthiness, leading her to dedicate her life to serving immigrants in the slums. Finola’s character is a study in contrasts; she is both strong-willed and vulnerable, determined to forge her own path yet burdened by the expectations of her family. Hedlund crafts Finola with a depth that makes her struggles and triumphs resonate with readers. Her journey is not just about finding love but also about finding herself and reconciling her past with her future.

Enter Riley Rafferty, a successful wagonmaker and a candidate in the St. Louis mayoral election. Riley is initially portrayed as a man driven by ambition, seeking a union with the Shanahan family to bolster his political aspirations. However, as the narrative unfolds, Riley emerges as a character of integrity and compassion, whose motivations are not solely self-serving. His interactions with Finola reveal layers of his personality, showcasing his ability to adapt and grow in the face of adversity.

The chemistry between Finola and Riley is palpable from their first meeting, and Hedlund skillfully builds their relationship with a blend of tension and tenderness. The matchmaker’s involvement adds an intriguing dynamic, as it forces both characters to confront their fears and desires. The romance is not rushed; instead, it develops organically, allowing readers to savor the gradual unfolding of their connection.

One of the novel’s strengths is its exploration of themes of love and sacrifice. Finola’s dedication to her work with immigrants highlights the sacrifices she makes for the greater good, while Riley’s political ambitions are tempered by his growing affection for Finola. The cholera outbreak serves as a catalyst for both characters to reevaluate their priorities, emphasizing the fragility of life and the importance of seizing the moment. Hedlund uses the historical setting to underscore the challenges faced by individuals in a rapidly changing world, drawing parallels to contemporary issues of social justice and public health.

Hedlund’s attention to historical detail enriches the narrative, immersing readers in the sights, sounds, and struggles of 19th-century St. Louis. The depiction of the cholera outbreak is particularly vivid, capturing the fear and uncertainty that gripped the city. This historical context adds depth to the story, providing a backdrop that enhances the characters’ personal journeys.

In terms of character development, Hedlund excels in creating multidimensional characters who evolve throughout the story. Finola’s transformation from a woman burdened by guilt to one who embraces her worth is both believable and inspiring. Similarly, Riley’s journey from a politically motivated candidate to a man who values love and partnership over ambition is handled with nuance and sensitivity.

Comparatively, Calling on the Matchmaker shares thematic similarities with other historical romances, such as those by authors like Julie Klassen and Tessa Dare. Like Klassen, Hedlund weaves faith and personal growth into her narrative, while her attention to historical accuracy and character-driven storytelling is reminiscent of Dare’s work. However, Hedlund’s unique voice and her focus on the Irish immigrant experience set this novel apart, offering readers a fresh perspective within the genre.

Overall, Calling on the Matchmaker is a beautifully crafted tale that balances romance, history, and social commentary. Jody Hedlund’s ability to create compelling characters and an engaging plot ensures that readers will be captivated from start to finish. The novel’s exploration of love, sacrifice, and self-discovery resonates on multiple levels, making it a standout addition to the historical romance genre.

For readers seeking a story that combines heartwarming romance with historical depth, Calling on the Matchmaker is a must-read. Hedlund’s skillful storytelling and rich character development make this novel a memorable journey into the complexities of love and the enduring power of hope.