In Erin McCarthy's But First, Whiskey, readers are treated to a delightful blend of romance, humor, and the complexities of relationships that arise when boundaries are crossed. The story revolves around Faith Young, a character who embodies the essence of youthful rebellion and charm, and her unexpected entanglement with her brother's best friend, a trope that has been explored in various forms but is executed here with a refreshing twist.

The narrative kicks off with a dramatic moment that sets the tone for the entire book. When the protagonist, whose name remains undisclosed in the blurb, jumps into a pond to save Faith, it marks the beginning of a series of events that will challenge their friendship, loyalty, and personal boundaries. This initial encounter is not just a plot device; it serves as a catalyst for the ensuing romantic tension that McCarthy skillfully develops throughout the book.

One of the standout themes in But First, Whiskey is the concept of forbidden love. The relationship between Faith and her brother's best friend is fraught with complications, primarily due to the unspoken rules of the "bro code." McCarthy navigates this theme with a deft hand, allowing readers to feel the weight of the characters' decisions. The protagonist's internal struggle—balancing his attraction to Faith with his loyalty to his best friend, Cash—creates a palpable tension that keeps readers engaged. This tension is further amplified by the protagonist's decision to offer Faith a job at his whiskey distillery as a means of keeping their night together a secret. While some might label this as blackmail, McCarthy frames it as a mutually beneficial arrangement, showcasing the complexities of adult relationships.

Character development is another area where McCarthy excels. Faith is portrayed as a vibrant and spirited young woman who is not afraid to challenge the status quo. Her character arc is compelling; she evolves from being the "little sister" into a confident woman who knows what she wants. This transformation is mirrored in her interactions with the protagonist, where she often challenges his grumpy demeanor and pushes him out of his comfort zone. The chemistry between the two is electric, and McCarthy captures their flirtation with wit and humor, making their banter one of the highlights of the book.

The protagonist, on the other hand, embodies the classic "grumpy hero" archetype. His initial reluctance to acknowledge his feelings for Faith adds depth to his character. As the story progresses, readers witness his gradual transformation from a man who is trying to maintain control to someone who is willing to embrace vulnerability for the sake of love. This character growth is not only believable but also relatable, as it reflects the struggles many face when navigating romantic relationships.

McCarthy's writing style is engaging and accessible, making it easy for readers to immerse themselves in the story. The dialogue is sharp and witty, often laced with humor that lightens the more serious moments. The author has a knack for creating vivid imagery, particularly in scenes that take place at the whiskey distillery, where the atmosphere is almost palpable. The setting becomes a character in its own right, enhancing the overall experience of the narrative.

Another notable aspect of But First, Whiskey is its exploration of family dynamics. Faith's relationship with her brother, Cash, adds another layer of complexity to the story. Cash's protective nature towards Faith is relatable and adds tension, especially as the protagonist grapples with the implications of his actions. This familial bond is portrayed with authenticity, showcasing the challenges that arise when personal desires conflict with familial loyalty.

The book also touches on themes of ambition and career aspirations. Faith's journey towards securing a job at the distillery is not just about her relationship with the protagonist; it also reflects her desire to carve out her own identity separate from her brother's shadow. This theme resonates with many readers, particularly young adults navigating their own paths in life.

In comparison to other contemporary romance novels, But First, Whiskey stands out for its unique setting and character dynamics. While the "forbidden love" trope is common, McCarthy's approach feels fresh and engaging. Readers who enjoy the works of authors like Christina Lauren or Tessa Bailey will likely find themselves captivated by McCarthy's storytelling style and character-driven narrative.

Overall, But First, Whiskey is a delightful read that combines humor, romance, and the complexities of adult relationships. Erin McCarthy has crafted a story that is both entertaining and thought-provoking, inviting readers to reflect on the nature of love, loyalty, and personal growth. The chemistry between the characters is undeniable, and their journey is one that many will find relatable. Whether you're a fan of contemporary romance or simply looking for a light-hearted escape, this book is sure to leave you with a smile and perhaps a craving for whiskey.