Penny Reid’s Beauty and the Mustache is a delightful addition to the Knitting in the City series, offering readers a charming blend of romance, humor, and personal growth. Set against the backdrop of small-town Tennessee, the story revolves around Ashley Winston, a former beauty queen with a complicated family history, who finds herself grappling with her past while navigating her feelings for the enigmatic Drew Runous.

From the outset, Reid introduces us to Ashley, a character defined by her escapism. With six brothers, a strained relationship with her father, and a penchant for reading and knitting, Ashley embodies the struggle many face when trying to reconcile their roots with their aspirations. Her return to her hometown following a family tragedy serves as a catalyst for her journey of self-discovery. Reid expertly captures the tension between Ashley's desire to escape and her growing connection to her family and community, making her a relatable protagonist.

Drew Runous, the local game warden, is a character who stands out not only for his rugged charm but also for his philosophical musings. His character is a refreshing departure from the typical romantic lead; he is not just a handsome face but a man with depth and intellect. The dynamic between Ashley and Drew is electric, filled with witty banter and palpable chemistry. Reid’s ability to weave humor into their interactions adds a layer of lightheartedness to the narrative, making their romance feel both genuine and entertaining.

One of the central themes of Beauty and the Mustache is the idea of home and belonging. Ashley’s journey back to Tennessee forces her to confront her past and the relationships she has tried to escape. Reid skillfully explores the complexities of familial bonds, particularly the love-hate relationship Ashley has with her brothers. Each brother, with their distinct personalities and quirks, adds depth to the story, showcasing the importance of family support and the challenges of reconciling with one’s roots.

Reid’s writing shines in her ability to create vivid imagery and relatable dialogue. The small-town setting is brought to life through her descriptions, making readers feel as if they are part of the community. The knitting group, a recurring element in the series, serves as a comforting backdrop, symbolizing friendship and support. The camaraderie among the women in the group is heartwarming and adds a layer of warmth to the narrative, reminding readers of the importance of female friendships.

Character development is another strong suit of Reid’s storytelling. Ashley’s evolution from a woman seeking escape to one who embraces her past is beautifully portrayed. Her internal struggles and eventual acceptance of her life choices resonate with readers, making her journey one of empowerment. Drew, too, undergoes growth as he learns to balance his philosophical outlook with the realities of love and relationships. Their mutual growth is a testament to the idea that love can be a transformative force.

The humor in Beauty and the Mustache is a standout feature. Reid’s witty writing style keeps the narrative engaging, with laugh-out-loud moments that lighten the heavier themes of the story. The playful banter between Ashley and Drew is particularly enjoyable, showcasing Reid’s talent for crafting dialogue that feels authentic and relatable. This humor not only entertains but also serves to deepen the emotional connection between the characters, making their romance all the more satisfying.

In comparison to other contemporary romantic comedies, Reid’s work stands out for its blend of humor, heart, and character depth. Readers who enjoy authors like Christina Lauren or Tessa Bailey will find much to love in Reid’s writing. Her ability to create complex characters and intertwine their personal journeys with romance sets her apart in the genre. The balance of lighthearted moments with more serious themes creates a well-rounded narrative that appeals to a wide audience.

Overall, Beauty and the Mustache is a captivating read that combines humor, romance, and personal growth in a way that feels both fresh and familiar. Penny Reid has crafted a story that not only entertains but also resonates on a deeper level, exploring themes of family, belonging, and the transformative power of love. Ashley and Drew’s journey is one that will linger in the minds of readers long after the last page is turned, making this book a must-read for fans of contemporary romance.

For those interested in diving into this charming tale, Beauty and the Mustache is available on platforms like Amazon and Goodreads.