Are You There, Moriarty? by A.E. Lister is an intriguing title that hints at the playful and enigmatic nature of the novel itself. This book takes readers on a literary journey that is as intellectually stimulating as it is amusing, weaving together themes of mystery, identity, and narrative nuances, which embroider the essence of Sherlock Holmes into a contemporary setting. Lister’s novel is not just a homage to the works of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle but an innovative narrative that challenges the boundaries of traditional storytelling.

The premise of Are You There, Moriarty? revolves around the lives of two main characters, Eliza and James, who are both professors specializing in Victorian literature. Throughout the book, their paths cross in a series of debates and discussions centered around one of literature's greatest mysteries – the enigmatic relationship between Sherlock Holmes and his arch-nemesis Professor Moriarty. Lister cleverly uses the metaphor of this rivalry to explore modern issues of rivalry, obsession, and intellectual combat.

Eliza, a sharp-witted scholar with a penchant for cryptography, finds herself entangled in a real-life mystery that mirrors the convoluted plots of the Holmesian novels she studies. James, on the other hand, is an expert in psychological profiling, his personality reflecting the calculated and sometimes cold logic of Holmes himself. Their interaction is filled with witty banter, reminiscent of Holmes and Watson’s dialogues, yet charged with an intellectual tension that keeps the reader engrossed. It is through their alliance and eventual confrontation with a shadowy figure who embodies Moriarty-like characteristics that the novel reaches its climactic culmination.

Lister's writing style is both elegant and accessible, crafting dialogues and descriptions that paint vivid scenes in the reader’s mind. The language used throughout the novel not only serves to propel the plot but also doubles as a delightful exercise in literary exploration for enthusiasts of Victorian literature. The clever intertextuality, weaving quotes and scenarios from Doyle's works into the fabric of this modern narrative, enriches the reading experience, offering layers of understanding that vary from the obvious to the subtly inferred.

A particularly commendable aspect of Are You There, Moriarty? is how Lister manages to balance a complex plot with character development. Both Eliza and James are deeply fleshed out, with backstories and emotional arcs that make them relatable and real. Their personal struggles, intertwined with their professional passions, offer a poignant look at how our histories and ambitions shape who we are and how we view the world. This dual focus on characters and intrigue does not detract from the pacing of the story; instead, it enriches the build-up to the suspense-filled denouement.

The book also subtly addresses themes of gender and power dynamics in academia, a reflective mirror to the dominance struggles between Holmes and Moriarty. Through Eliza’s experiences in the male-dominated world of literary scholarship, Lister critiques contemporary societal norms and champions a message of resilience and equality. These thematic threads are woven with a light touch, however, ensuring that the narrative remains entertaining while thought-provoking.

Moreover, the metafictional elements of the novel provide an additional layer of enjoyment. Lister occasionally breaks the fourth wall, pulling readers into the story to question our perceptions of the characters and the writer’s intent. This playful manipulation of narrative perspective not only ties into the Holmesian theme of observation and deduction but also encourages readers to become detectives themselves, piecing together the clues scattered throughout the text.

In conclusion, Are You There, Moriarty? by A.E. Lister is a delightful and cleverly crafted novel that will appeal to fans of Sherlock Holmes and lovers of thrillers alike. Its blend of mystery, intellectual debate, and character-driven narrative makes it not only a compelling read but also a thoughtful examination of the lingering impact of Victorian literature on modern-day issues. The book challenges its readers to look beyond the surface of its characters and plots, inviting them to engage in a deeper exploration of the themes presented. Whether you are a longtime aficionado of detective stories or a newcomer to the genre, this novel is sure to engage and entertain, leaving you contemplating its intricate puzzles long after the final page is turned.