Always Alchemy by Elodie Hart is a captivating journey into a world where the boundaries between magic and reality blur, creating a tapestry rich with intrigue, romance, and mystery. This novel, Hart's third publication, solidifies her reputation as a gifted storyteller capable of crafting beautifully layered plots and complex characters that resonate deeply with readers. Set in a meticulously detailed universe, Hart combines elements of traditional fantasy with a modern twist, making it a refreshing addition to the genre.

The novel introduces us to Alayna, a young woman who has just discovered that she is an Alchemist—one of the few who possess the power to manipulate elements. The revelation comes as she inherits an ancient book and a mysterious amulet from her late grandmother, a renowned alchemist herself. The story unfolds in the fictional city of Galdor, a place that feels both timeless and vibrant, thanks to Hart’s descriptive prowess. The narrative expertly weaves Alayna's personal growth with her exploration of alchemy’s potential.

One of Hart's strengths is her ability to create multi-dimensional characters that evolve continually throughout the story. Alayna, the protagonist, is particularly compelling. She is not only battling external forces but also grappling with her internal conflicts, especially her fear of wielding her newfound powers. Her vulnerability and strength make her a relatable and inspiring figure. The supporting characters are equally well-developed, from the enigmatic mentor figure, Master Corin, to her steadfast friend, Theo, who brings a light-hearted balance to the more intense moments of the plot.

The theme of self-discovery is central to Always Alchemy. Hart skilfully portrays Alayna’s transformation as she learns more about her powers and her past. This journey is not just about mastering alchemy but also about understanding the importance of choice, responsibility, and trust. Hart’s exploration of these themes is thoughtful and resonant, providing a deeper meaning beneath the entertaining façade of the adventure and magic.

The romance element of Always Alchemy deserves a special mention. It is wonderfully woven into the main storyline, enhancing rather than overwhelming the narrative. The chemistry between Alayna and another key character, whose name to reveal would be a spoiler, develops in a manner that is both believable and enchanting. Their relationship adds another layer of complexity to the story, as it intertwines with the larger narrative arcs concerning fate, power, and the use of alchemy.

Elodie Hart also impresses with her world-building skills. Galdor is not just a backdrop for the action; it is a living, breathing entity that plays a crucial role in the story. The social and political dynamics of the city, the detailed descriptions of its landscapes and the rules of magic create a world that is immersive and convincing. The author’s meticulous attention to detail ensures that readers are fully invested in this world, making the stakes of the novel feel real and urgent.

However, the book is not without its minor flaws. At times, the pacing seems uneven, particularly in the middle section where the narrative occasionally dips into slower, more introspective passages that, while important for character development, might deter readers seeking constant action. Additionally, some may find the use of modern dialogue jarring against the otherwise classical setting, although this could also be seen as a deliberate choice to make the story more accessible to contemporary audiences.

Despite these minor criticisms, Always Alchemy is a masterful blend of fantasy, adventure, and romance. It certainly stands as a testament to Hart’s evolving skill and creativity. The novel ends satisfactorily yet leaves enough questions unanswered and potentials unexplored, which could ideally set the stage for a sequel—or better yet, a series. Readers who enjoy strong character development, intricate plot twists, and a well-constructed magical world will find this book to be a delightful read.

In conclusion, Always Alchemy by Elodie Hart is a significant contribution to the fantasy genre. It combines the right amount of mystery, character growth, and magic to keep readers engaged from start to finish. For those who are fans of authors like Leigh Bardugo and Sarah J. Maas, Elodie Hart’s latest novel is definitely worth picking up. The journey of Alayna not only entertains but also inspires, making Always Alchemy a resonant and memorable read.