Nicole French’s A Winding Wave of Magic is a captivating entry into the romantasy genre, blending elements of romance, fantasy, and suspense into a narrative that is both engaging and thought-provoking. The book's premise, centered around the concept of fated mates, is a familiar trope in fantasy literature, yet French manages to infuse it with fresh energy and complexity, making it feel both epic and intimate.

At the heart of the story is Cassandra Whelan, a character who defies the typical damsel-in-distress archetype. Instead, she is portrayed as a bookish student, more comfortable with spells than social interactions. This characterization is both relatable and refreshing, as it allows readers to see a protagonist who is strong in her own right, yet still vulnerable and evolving. Cassandra's journey from a student to someone who must navigate the treacherous waters of magical politics and ancient secrets is compelling and well-paced.

Jonathan Lynch, her fated mate, is an intriguing counterpart. As a one-hundred-and-twelve-year-old fae, he carries the weight of centuries of secrets and experiences. His character is a study in contrasts—brooding yet protective, powerful yet haunted by his past. The age gap between Cassandra and Jonathan adds an additional layer of complexity to their relationship, challenging both characters to confront their own biases and fears. This dynamic is reminiscent of other age-gap romances in fantasy, such as those found in Sarah J. Maas's works, yet French's approach feels uniquely her own.

The chemistry between Cassandra and Jonathan is palpable, and French skillfully navigates the tension between them. Their relationship is fraught with challenges, not least of which is the violent possessiveness that Jonathan feels—a trait that is both a blessing and a curse. This possessiveness is not portrayed as a simple romantic trope but is instead explored as a dangerous and multifaceted aspect of their bond. The author does not shy away from the darker implications of such a connection, adding depth to the narrative.

The world-building in A Winding Wave of Magic is another standout feature. French creates a rich tapestry of magical elements, from Cassandra's haunted inheritance to the powerful magical council she becomes a part of. The lore surrounding the fae and the centuries-old secret they guard is intricately woven into the plot, providing a backdrop that is both expansive and immersive. The stakes are high, and the sense of danger is ever-present, keeping readers on the edge of their seats.

One of the book's most compelling themes is the idea of destiny versus choice. Cassandra and Jonathan's bond is described as being "written in the stars," yet both characters struggle with the implications of this predestined connection. French explores the tension between accepting one's fate and forging one's own path, a theme that resonates deeply in a world where personal agency is often at odds with societal expectations. This exploration of destiny is reminiscent of works by authors like Deborah Harkness, where characters must navigate the fine line between fate and free will.

The narrative is further enriched by the inclusion of murder and intrigue, elements that add a layer of suspense to the story. The secrets that both Cassandra and Jonathan harbor are not just personal but have far-reaching consequences that could "torch worlds." This sense of impending doom is expertly balanced with moments of levity and romance, creating a well-rounded and satisfying reading experience.

French's writing style is both lyrical and accessible, drawing readers into the story with vivid descriptions and well-crafted dialogue. The decision to expand upon previously published novellas and add an additional 50,000 words provides a more comprehensive and satisfying conclusion to the story, allowing for greater character development and plot resolution.

In comparison to other romantasy novels, A Winding Wave of Magic stands out for its nuanced characters and intricate plot. While it shares similarities with works by authors like Jennifer L. Armentrout and C.L. Wilson, French's novel is distinguished by its focus on the internal struggles of its protagonists and the moral complexities of their world.

Overall, A Winding Wave of Magic is a must-read for fans of the romantasy genre. Its blend of romance, magic, and suspense creates a story that is both epic in scope and deeply personal. Nicole French has crafted a tale that not only entertains but also challenges readers to consider the nature of destiny, love, and sacrifice. For those looking for a book that will keep them enthralled from beginning to end, this novel is an excellent choice.