Trisha Messmer's A Duke in the Rough is a delightful foray into the world of Regency romance, where titles and social standing often overshadow true love. This novel, with its engaging premise and well-drawn characters, offers a fresh take on the classic trope of mistaken identity and the quest for genuine affection amidst societal expectations.

At the heart of the story is the newly minted Duke of Burwood, Drake Merrick, whose unexpected rise to nobility sets the stage for a series of romantic entanglements and personal revelations. Drake's character is a fascinating study in contrasts. Once a lowly groom, he is thrust into the upper echelons of society, a world he views with skepticism and a touch of disdain. His past experiences have left him jaded, particularly his belief that aristocratic women are more enamored with titles than with the men who hold them. This cynicism is both his strength and his Achilles' heel, driving the central conflict of the novel.

Lady Honoria Bell, the female protagonist, is equally compelling. Her past heartbreak has left her wary of love, yet she remains a spirited and independent character, determined to navigate the treacherous waters of Regency society on her own terms. Honoria's journey is one of self-discovery and resilience, as she grapples with her feelings for Drake and the societal pressures imposed by her father, the Marquess. Her character is a refreshing departure from the typical damsel in distress, offering readers a heroine who is both relatable and admirable.

The novel's central theme revolves around the idea of authenticity versus deception. Drake's decision to switch places with his man of business is a clever narrative device that allows Messmer to explore the superficial nature of Regency courtship. This theme is further underscored by the various suitors who pursue Honoria, each more interested in her dowry and connections than in her as a person. Through these interactions, Messmer critiques the transactional nature of marriage during this period, highlighting the challenges faced by individuals seeking genuine connections in a world governed by social contracts.

Messmer's writing is both witty and poignant, capturing the nuances of Regency society with a deft touch. Her dialogue is sharp and often humorous, providing a counterbalance to the more serious themes of the novel. The banter between Drake and Honoria is particularly enjoyable, showcasing their chemistry and the underlying tension that drives their relationship. This dynamic is reminiscent of the works of Julia Quinn and Tessa Dare, who similarly blend humor and romance to great effect.

One of the novel's strengths lies in its secondary characters, who add depth and richness to the story. From Honoria's well-meaning but overbearing father to Drake's loyal man of business, each character is carefully crafted to enhance the narrative. These supporting roles provide additional layers to the plot, offering insights into the societal norms and expectations of the time.

However, the novel is not without its flaws. Some readers may find the pacing uneven, particularly in the middle sections where the plot occasionally meanders. Additionally, while the resolution is satisfying, it may feel somewhat predictable to seasoned romance readers. Despite these minor quibbles, the overall impact of the story remains strong, leaving readers with a sense of hope and the belief that love can indeed conquer all.

In comparison to other Regency romances, A Duke in the Rough stands out for its exploration of identity and the importance of being true to oneself. Messmer's ability to weave these themes into a compelling love story is commendable, making the novel a worthwhile addition to the genre. Fans of Eloisa James and Mary Balogh will likely appreciate Messmer's nuanced approach to character development and her keen insight into the human heart.

In conclusion, A Duke in the Rough is a charming and thought-provoking read that will appeal to fans of historical romance and those new to the genre alike. Trisha Messmer has crafted a story that is both entertaining and meaningful, reminding us that love, in its truest form, transcends titles and societal expectations. For readers seeking a romance that is both heartfelt and intelligent, this novel is a must-read.